The Shame of Prometheus
The Greek myth suits today’s tech giants, but not for the reason they think.
Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.
START FREE TRIAL NOWThe Shame of Prometheus
The Greek myth suits today’s tech giants, but not for the reason they think.
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]In November 2025,[.small-caps] Jeff Bezos founded an AI company and named it after the ancient Greek hero who stole fire from the gods. In September 2026 in south Texas, a fifty-foot statue of Prometheus was erected outside the launch base of Elon Musk’s SpaceX. In California, a cryptocurrency billionaire named Ross Calvin has announced his intention to build a 450-foot statue of Prometheus on the island of Alcatraz – a taller rival to the Statue of Liberty. Beneath it will stand the “Prometheion Museum” dedicated to breakthrough technologies.[.article__paragraph--cap]
The great German thinker Günther Anders would not be surprised that, almost thirty-five years after his death, men of great power and wealth are still attracted to the Prometheus myth. But their reverence for the Greek legend, he would argue, has less to do with pride than with unconscious shame. “We have usually associated the figure of Prometheus with ‘hubris,’” Anders wrote in 1956. “If we ask ourselves whether this figure still has validity and allegorical significance for the representation of our contemporaries … we arrive at … ambivalent answers.” In his day, Anders must have been aware of the statue of Prometheus in Rockefeller Plaza in New York, or the one in MacArthur Park in Los Angeles, having lived in both cities. He knew that midcentury America was teeming with ambitious businessmen. “Our contemporaries are certainly still ‘Prometheans,’” he wrote, as they “have presumptuously self-aggrandizing ideas of entitlement – but these are so aggrandizing that they begin to feel inadequate themselves.”
These lines come from The Obsolescence of the Human, Anders’s greatest work, the first volume of which was published in 2025 in a new translation by the University of Minnesota Press. Forgotten today except by a smattering of professors, in his life Anders studied philosophy under the leading lights of twentieth-century German thought – Husserl, Heidegger, and Adorno were all his teachers – but never became a full professor. A Jew, Anders fled Hitler’s Germany in 1933 and spent the war years in the United States, working intermittently as a lecturer at the New School in New York, and in a costume warehouse in Hollywood, before returning to Europe in 1950. Before the war, he was briefly married to Hannah Arendt, who, Anders later admitted, found his pessimism “hard to bear.”
Anders believed that human beings had created a world that no longer needed them. Industrialization and, especially, the postwar consumer society that it spawned, had generated an environment where human beings “must simultaneously be ‘themselves’ and not be ‘themselves.’” We feel shame – a “Promethean shame,” he calls it – for being deficient machines. Machines are sleek, functional, powerful, and have a long shelf life. Unlike humans here on earth who live, in Anders’s words, a “lifetime in obsolete singularity and uniqueness,” machines enjoy “a new variety of immortality,” a form of “industrial reincarnation … the existence of serial products.” Moreover, machines always have a prescribed role which defines their existence, whereas human beings are burdened by a free will, contradictory impulses, logistical problems, moral dilemmas, and, eventually, a slow and unpleasant physical and mental decline. The world is now becoming a home for machines, and in order to fit into an economy that is largely built and run by machines, human beings must become more like them. But while humans feel compelled to become machines, they know that the effort is ultimately futile. Hence the Promethean shame, which infects not only the working and professional classes but also the titans of industry. In fact, they feel the shame most acutely. It isn’t Zeus who punishes today’s Prometheans. Rather, they punish themselves “on account of their own ‘backwardness’ and ‘the shame of having been born.’”
The Obsolescence of Man is at once an intimidating tome of German philosophy and a work of horror. The arguments are numbered, and they proceed methodically, from premise to premise, subheading to subheading, with the steady rhythm of a dirge. Unlike his German teachers, Anders tailors his sentences for clarity. At the same time, the further one gets into his argument and the deeper one ventures into his mind, the more hysterical the atmosphere becomes. Surely, he is exaggerating. One after another, the insights into how technology has deformed us pile up so high that at a certain point one wonders whether maybe it’s just the author who has the problem. Maybe Anders really was, as his ex-wife Hannah Arendt allegedly thought, too pessimistic.
Many readers would fall for this tempting conclusion, but for the fact that Anders was also, undoubtedly, a prophet. Consider some of the dystopian trends that Anders could already detect, in embryonic form, in the fifties, and which everyone can easily see today. Today we have a vast industry of lifestyle influencers. Anders predicted their rise when he foresaw that communication technology and a consumer-centered economy would redefine privacy. In the modern economy, we want to become products; we want to sell ourselves and so we become, as he put it, “home-based workers.” One way to do this is to create images of ourselves for mass consumption. And we want these images to be attractive and salable – hence, among other things, the uptick in plastic surgery and the rise of what the writer Jia Tolentino has dubbed “Instagram face.” The phenomenon was already notable in Anders’s time. Instead of cultivating a private self at home and in moments of leisure, we would spend our time crafting a public image of ourselves for the market. He called this “Hollywood privacy,” which he argued was “an entirely new type of ‘privacy,’” which “seeks to hide everything that could become detrimental to the validity of images.”
Influencers are, of course, central protagonists of the social media economy, whose pathologies Anders also dimly foresaw. Today we speak of “social media addiction.” Anders described a world where human beings of all ages would be transformed “into soloistic empaths or eavesdroppers and voyeurs.” Today we speak about people developing “parasocial relationships” with the media personalities whose podcasts they listen to or whose social media accounts they follow. In a funny passage in Obsolescence, Anders is appalled by old women who, according to him, would speak of characters from soap operas as if they were real-life family members. Beyond the social media economy, Anders even anticipates modes of resistance to it, such as what today is known as “friction-maxxing” – an anti-tech lifestyle trend that favors the cumbersome and complicated over the streamlined and automated. “Contemporary man produces frictions as consumer goods,” Anders wrote.
With the rise of LLMs and chatbots, many are worried about the effects of “cognitive offloading” for our brains. This offloading can also be ethical, as in the phenomenon of “algorithmic deference,” where people outsource their moral choices to computers. Anders also foresaw a time when we would delegate decisions to what he called an “electric brain.” He believed it was part of our long slide to obsolescence. “Anyone who transfers responsibility from a human being to a machine also transforms their own responsibility,” he writes. It is as if humanity “publicly said to itself: Because we aren’t as good at calculating as our machine, we are unreliable and incapable of taking responsibility, so let’s not ‘make decisions’ anymore.”
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Another aspect[.small-caps] of Anders’s prophecy, however, seems to miss the mark – at least at first blush. In the fourth essay of Obsolescence, Anders writes about our post-Hiroshima “apocalypse blindness.” The reason for this blindness is our stubborn belief in “progress.” “In times past, eschatological hope was automatically supplemented by apocalyptic fear,” he writes. “The generations-old belief in the apparently automatic progression of history has robbed us of our ability to anticipate the ‘end.’” The existence of the atomic bomb makes this apocalypse blindness extremely dangerous. If we cannot imagine the apocalypse, if we are in denial about the fact that the bomb could bring it about, then we will not do enough to prevent it from happening.[.article__paragraph--cap]
Anders believed that the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and subsequent development of even more destructive weapons, generated a new form of Promethean shame, different than the one before. The atomic bomb created a vast gulf between our sheer power to destroy, which is now unprecedented in scope, and our power to fathom, or even picture, the very destruction we could wreak upon the world. We simply cannot get our heads around the bomb, and we wish we were not actually responsible for it. “The bomb and nihilism are one and the same,” he writes. And yet, “When the man of today spouts his unfiltered commentary on the current state of the world … he couldn’t care less whether the existence of the bomb points to the meaninglessness of existence or whether this meaninglessness is in turn used to legitimate the existence of the bomb. So much so that he isn’t even sure himself which way he’s arguing.”
Today, Anders’s account of “apocalypse blindness” rings false for two reasons. The obvious one is that we no longer fear the atomic bomb as much as we should. Instead, we fear climate change or, especially now, artificial intelligence as potential causes for the end of civilization. But the fear of AI suggests another difference. Everyone knows that our tech leaders, all believers in progress, do not suffer from apocalypse blindness. Quite the contrary. Routinely over the past ten years, some of the smartest, wealthiest, and most powerful people in America have been telling us: “We will see the end of the human race as we know it, and soon.” That is, within our lifetimes. Actually, within a decade.
The list of the accumulated prophecies, predictions, and foreboding remarks is staggering. The most optimistic prophets foretell that humanity will fuse with an artificial superintelligence (ASI) and become a race of cyborgs. Sam Altman, the CEO of OpenAI, expresses this view in a famous blog post, “The Merge,” published in 2017: “We will be the first species ever to design our own descendants. My guess is that we can either be the biological bootloader for digital intelligence and then fade into an evolutionary tree branch, or we can figure out what a successful merge looks like.” Altman’s statement hints at another, darker, possibility: that human beings will become absorbed and domesticated by ASI, forsake their autonomy, and survive only as the machine’s pet. Elon Musk, founder of, among other things, the AI model Grok, supports this view. “Long-term, AI’s going to be in charge,” he said in a speech in 2025. “Not humans. If artificial intelligence vastly exceeds the sum of human intelligence, it is difficult to imagine any humans would actually be in charge.”
A third school of thought foresees the imminent death of all human beings at the hands of AI. By now, everyone has heard some version of this prophecy. I will note the one that stuck with me, because it was uttered by Geoffrey Hinton, the computer scientist known as the godfather of artificial intelligence. In 2024, Hinton told the Guardian that there was a “10 to 20 percent chance that AI would lead to human extinction within the next three decades.”
All of the people I’ve cited are powerful or wealthy, or at least influential. They have Promethean ambitions, whether in business or science. They definitely do not seem to suffer from apocalypse blindness. Nor do they, for that matter, appear burdened by the type of intellectual or moral insecurity that Anders calls Promethean shame.
Or do they? Consider the fact that the people who are warning us about an AI apocalypse are the same ones who are helping to build AI. They could stop building it, but they don’t. Instead, they speak from both sides of their mouths: “Stop, in the name of humanity!” on one side, and “Let it rip!” on the other. Dario Amodei, the CEO of Anthropic, for example, recently announced that “the AI industry should slow down,” but Anthropic continues to build. Elon Musk and Sam Altman both publicly announced that they agreed with Amodei, but they also continue developing their own models. “If you’re building Frankenstein, stop,” Vice President J. D. Vance said to the titans of industry. Their answer seems to be: “Yes, we are building Frankenstein; but no, we will not stop. We might slow down. Please make us slow down. In any case, we will take breaks to warn you about what’s coming.” Ironically, the leaders of Anduril and Palantir, defense companies that design AI products for the battlefield – in other words, the men who might actually cause a catastrophic war and most directly lead us to an apocalypse – tend to downplay the AI doomer prophecies. It’s all rather confusing. The public belief that the tech CEOs hold the reins to a potentially world-destroying machine gives them power. So, while not blind to a possible apocalypse, it’s unclear how much these leaders of AI actually believe in their dark prophecies. Like Anders’s proverbial man who offers “unfiltered commentary” about the atomic bomb, these CEOs aren’t even sure themselves which way they are arguing. Their efforts to stave off the apocalypse seem ambivalent.
Also exhibiting a strange combination of apocalyptic feeling and Promethean shame are those statements from scientists and writers which actually seem to welcome an AI apocalypse, one wherein human beings continue to exist, but subservient to superior AI masters. “Succession to AI is inevitable,” said computer scientist Richard Sutton in 2023. Sutton, a Fellow of the Royal Society, winner of the Turing Award, co-creator of Google DeepMind, believes this is a good thing: While AI “could displace us from existence … we should not resist succession, but embrace and prepare for it. … Why would we want greater beings kept subservient?” Scott Alexander, writer of the Substack Astral Codex Ten, much beloved in Silicon Valley, believes that once ASI is smart enough, we should allow it to run the US government:
Every vision of the utopian future agrees we will have robot servants. And the president, they tell us, is merely a public servant. Why should he alone be exempt from the vision? . . . If we do build a godlike AI, and determine to our own satisfaction that it’s fully aligned, I’d rather let it choose its own direction for itself and for humanity than have it be under the control of the US president, or a shareholder vote, or anything like that. So why not just prompt it with “please arrange the universe as you see fit”?
Sutton and Alexander exhibit all the marks of Promethean shame. They admire the superior intelligence of machines, while failing to find a satisfying place for human beings in an ASI-governed future. Moreover, they see a clear, untroubled future for ASI, unlike the violent and uncertain history of human beings. Alexander predicts an apocalypse will come if we do not allow AI to run our government. “Reject [AI], and I predict that all of the curses prophesied by [the biblical prophet] Samuel will fall upon you,” he writes. “Your kings will keep taking your sons for pointless wars, giving the fruits of your labors to their cronies, etc., etc. There will be more curses too – surveillance states, reeducation camps, mind control, the whole litany of horrors the twentieth century discovered, plus some extra for the twenty-first.”
But the ultimate mark of apocalyptic fervor and Promethean shame in Silicon Valley is a belief in transhumanism, a surprisingly popular worldview that holds that AI will somehow make it possible for human beings to live forever. The rub is that human beings will live forever in the form of a computer program. AI will make it possible to upload our brains onto computers. In 2005, Ray Kurzweil, a brilliant computer scientist who perhaps has done more than anyone else to promote transhumanism, predicted that uploading would be possible by 2045. Computer programs are, as we have seen, quasi-immortal: they can be replicated indefinitely. Add to this the awesome potential of ASI, and the future begins to look like it is the exclusive province of machines. No computer scientist or CEO has been able to express the Promethean shame of Silicon Valley as eloquently as Grimes, the Canadian pop singer who shares three children with Elon Musk. From “I Wanna Be Software”:
I wanna be software
I wanna be code
Digital dancing
Upload my soul
From “We Appreciate Power”:
And if you long to never die
Baby, plug in, upload your mind
Come on, you’re not even alive
If you’re not backed up on a drive
And from “Artificial Angels”:
This is what it feels like to be hunted by something
smarter than you
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Two things happen[.small-caps] to Prometheus after he steals fire from the gods. First, an angry Zeus fastens him to the side of a mountain, his body exposed while an eagle pecks at his liver, which grows back after every meal. Second – and this is my gloss – he leaves behind an ambiguous legacy. Fire can keep you warm, or burn down your house. It can nurture or destroy. Because of Prometheus’s gift, the human race is forced to find a way of living with the fire – of using it for life, but most importantly, of curbing its destructive uses. Periodically, we will fail to fully control this new power. But it will survive. Should the human race thank Prometheus for such a gift?[.article__paragraph--cap]
As with fire, so with other technologies. “This system of devices is our ‘world,’” writes Anders. The devices change the world with their very presence, by opening up new possibilities for action, and making new habits and forms of life possible and easier than ever before. “The assumption that we have freedom of use and power over technology is a mere illusion,” he writes, “as is the belief that certain parts of our world are nothing but ‘means’ (to which ‘good ends’ can be attached at will). … Our technology-suffused existence doesn’t break up into individual, neatly demarcated sections, each marked either with a road sign ‘means’ or ‘end.’” This doesn’t mean that technology is evil, nor does it mean that we should not be grateful for the many new technologies which have improved the human lot (something Anders fails to be). But the birth of a new technology will always require a great effort of accommodation and adaption – an effort, that is, to forge a new, humane existence within the new world that the technology has created.
Those who would build a new, humane world with artificial intelligence would do well to find a better myth. Prometheus is ultimately a juvenile figure: he steals fire from Zeus the way a teenager might steal his parents’ car keys. Eventually, the father figure reimposes order in the form of punishment. The fact that many AI boosters dream of a world ruled by AI suggests that they are not dreaming of an adult utopia. Even though they believe in science and progress, they are abandoning the Enlightenment ideal of, in the words of Immanuel Kant, “emergence from man’s self-imposed immaturity,” and they are dreaming instead of new robot parents. The story of Abraham, which remains more popular than that of Prometheus, proposes a different relationship between God and human beings. Abraham doesn’t steal anything from God; God reveals himself to Abraham, and opens up a new path – a new way of life, a new world – for him and his descendants.
A truly human society, Anders contends, is one where “means and ends are so imbued by lifestyle and custom that it becomes impossible to recognize (or even ask) whether some specific part of life or the world is a ‘means’ or an ‘end.’ Humanity only begins where the way to the fountain is as good as the drink it supplies.” Prometheus is not the one to lead us there.