When Freedom Leads to Loneliness
What is the story of freedom that we’re telling ourselves that is leading to toxic loneliness?
Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.
START FREE TRIAL NOWWhen Freedom Leads to Loneliness
What is the story of freedom that we’re telling ourselves that is leading to toxic loneliness?
Joy Marie Clarkson: Welcome to Another Life, a podcast of Plough Quarterly. This episode is a part of our series on Friendship. On today’s episode, I speak with Michael Keller, the founding and senior pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church Lincoln Square. We talk about The Stories We Live By, a new book he wrote with his late father Tim Keller. This was a very special project that Michael and his father embarked upon in the final years of his father’s life, which was entrusted to Michael to finish.
In this episode, we speak particularly about how our culture’s narratives about freedom can lead us to what Michael describes as, quote, loneliness with better marketing. We spoke about how a meaningful life is not one free of restraints and commitments, but one in which we bind ourselves thoughtfully and prayerfully to places, people, and callings that matter. We talked about what it looks like to overcome those narratives of freedom that lead to loneliness.
Whether it’s becoming more willing to engage in conflict, more open to the beauty of a mundane life, or enjoying stories like Lord of the Rings and House, M.D. that help us imagine what it looks like to commit and work through meaningful friendships, even when they’re difficult. I hope you’ll enjoy this episode of Another Life.
Joy Marie Clarkson: We are the stories we live by. Welcome back everyone to Another Life, a podcast of Plough Quarterly. I am delighted to be welcoming you back to our series on friendship. And today I have the great pleasure of welcoming a guest to the show who’s going to speak to us about how our lives are shaped by stories and how we can think more critically about those stories and invite ourselves into new stories, into the Christian story.
So welcome to the show, Michael Keller.
Michael Keller: Thank you for having me, Joy. It’s great to be here.
Joy Marie Clarkson: So I’ll begin as I begin all our conversations, which is to ask you where you physically are in the world and how you spend your days. I can start with a quick answer, which is I’m in my little East London flat. So tell us where you are and how you spend your days.
Michael Keller: I am in my apartment of eleven hundred square feet in Manhattan, New York City. It’s where we’ve lived for a while. I’m looking out on Broadway right now with a lot of other apartment buildings. It’s a cloudless sky and it’s actually pretty good weather right now. I do not have a lot of insulation next to these windows, so you probably will hear a siren or two that goes by – or a honk or something, because that’s just the environment that I’m in right now. But that’s what I’m looking at.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Wonderful. And tell us a bit about how you spend your days when not talking on podcasts or writing books, which is apparently mostly new for you.
Michael Keller: Well yes, it is a new experience, but it’s still a joy to be here. I’m a senior pastor at Redeemer Lincoln Square. I planted a church for the past ten years that came out of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City. And so I spend most of my days being a full-time pastor and I love it. It’s the joys and sorrows of being with other embodied individuals here in the city.
Joy Marie Clarkson: I was just looking up the Lincoln Square Redeemer on a map because I think that actually my husband and I spent a Sunday at your church a few years ago. We were just in London, or not in London, were in New York for a visit and it happened to pass over a Sunday. So I think I might have actually worshipped in your church at one point.
Michael Keller: Yeah, Lincoln Square itself is a very small area of Manhattan, but it’s where the arts and culture center is with Lincoln Center. And it’s a lovely, lovely place. Anyway, we would love anyone that’s listening to come by sometime.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Well, I’m so glad to have you on today. And we’re going to talk about your book. Why don’t you tell us just a bit about the origins of this book that is, I’ll say, co-written, but in an unusual circumstance, with your father, Tim Keller.
Michael Keller: Yeah, we set out to write this book together before he died and as he was dying he said, Hey, you have all the materials, you have the chapter outlines, you have what we want to do. You write the book, put it out. And that’s what I’ve done. It’s taken a couple of years since he died to actually do that, but it was something that we wanted to do together and we did it.
More or less his arguments that he has made, and I found them on his computer, that we had talked about for a long time, but he had done a cultural analysis of some of the stories that our culture tells us. Nobody lives by arguments alone, nobody lives by postulates and statements. We live as storied individuals, and the book examines those stories and shows where we’ve absorbed them, what’s good about them, what we can affirm, what we can critique, and what we try to say is that these stories fit into a larger and better story, if we allow them.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Yes, I really loved getting to read through both the introduction and various chapters. I think it can come as a sort of – if you’re not a literarily minded person, we were doing our mic tests with Shakespeare and Chaucer but if you’re not a literary-minded person, then saying something like, “We live by stories” can sound very airy fairy.
But I do think that one of the gifts of this book is that it helps you become aware of the stories that you are telling. And that we are telling together as a culture. And not to do that in a purely negative mode. I liked that one of the things that is talked about a lot is that the most powerful stories are ones that can gather other stories into themselves and situate them and re-narrate them.
The way that this is talked about in the book is the idea of a cultural narrative. So can you tell us a bit about what a cultural narrative is, or maybe a specific example would be helpful?
Michael Keller: Yeah, it’s a great question. The idea behind it is that as humans, we can’t live life without having certain questions answered. Who am I? What’s the point of reality? What went wrong with the world? What will put it right, what’s the purpose of the world? But very few of us ask those questions in an intellectual form. Maybe philosophers do, maybe certain individuals have asked those questions very consciously. But the reason why we don’t ask those questions is because unconsciously every culture has already answered those questions for us and they’re embodied in the movies, the music, the statements that we say to each other.
And those statements or cultural narratives actually hold many arguments that answer each one of those questions. So when you say when you hear somebody say on the street, Hey, you know, you should just follow your heart. That sounds like a throwaway statement, but it’s not. There there’s an argument inside that statement that answers what’s the point of why we should live. Or hey, you should just do what makes you happy.
That sounds like a throwaway statement, but it’s not. There’s a cultural story that’s embedded in that. Follow your heart, you do you, live free. And we go through seven of these stories in the book and we try to evaluate them. And again, we try to use a paradigm that is based on … I have to admit that as a pastor, my Christian worldview contains Genesis 1 that all things were created good, but Genesis 3 that all things are actually fallen. And so if all things are good but fallen, then that means even our stories have something that we can affirm and say was originally good, but also Genesis 3, there’s something fallen and marred about it that we can’t fully accept or hold. And so we try to do that in each chapter, looking at each one of these stories.
Joy Marie Clarkson: So one of the stories that you talk about, and is relevant for us is in this series that we’re doing on friendship, is the story of freedom, and how this can lead to a feeling to experiences of loneliness and division. So I’m going to read a little passage from the book. You say, By 2024, half of American adults reported measurable loneliness. The US Surgeon General declared loneliness as a public health epidemic, noting that social isolation carries a mortality risk equivalent to smoking fifteen cigarettes a day. The percentage of Americans who report that they have no close friendships has quadrupled since 1990, and 58 percent of Americans say they are always or sometimes feel like no one knows them well. As we have stripped away the constraints of community, we haven’t found more freedom. We have found a solitude so toxic that it’s literally killing us.
So this is in your chapter on freedom. What is the story of freedom that we’re telling ourselves that is leading to this kind of toxic loneliness?
Michael Keller: it’s actually a very Western story, as you were reading that little fragment there. It’s the idea that, if you could summarize it, that freedom is the absence of restrictions, live as you choose, just don’t harm anybody. I’ve heard this in so many different movies and music and statements just growing up in the city, but just this isn’t just a city thing. You’re almost born into this kind of concept that the way that you’re going to be able to get the identity that you want, the way that you’re going to get the happiness that you want, the way that you’re going get to be the person you’ve always wanted to be, is that you have freedom from the restrictions of the world to actually do that.
And what we can affirm about this is that freedom is a good thing. It is true that if you’re listen to the history of nations and people groups, there’s lots of oppression, there’s lots of people that have not been free to be able to do things that are good and right in the world. So we do need freedom. But where we’ve gone wrong is the idea that freedom from all restrictions is the best thing. The problem with that is that if you’re really free from everything, total optionality, total freedom from all bonds and ties, leads to loneliness. Because then you’re not bound to any community, you’re not bound to any person, and ultimately you don’t have love because love at its core is a commitment to someone or something else.
And so we try to show that. We try to show that that’s the problem.
Joy Marie Clarkson: I liked the illustration you gave of this was your dad learning the song from Frozen, “Let It Go,” which of course was … I don’t know how Disney does it, but there’s some capacity to get into child’s psyches, songs that will never leave. But you talk about that image of Elsa, and admittedly it’s probably been, however long it’s been since Frozen came out is as long since I’ve seen it. But she has this song “Let It Go” where she’s speaking about finding her freedom and going to this isolated little castle and finding freedom through total lack of connection or obligation to the rest of her family and her kingdom.
But then that causes this great frost and freezes her kingdom, quite literally, which I found charming as an illustration. Also to know that your dad, like many other grandparents, had that in his repertoire of things too.
Michael Keller: He memorized the whole thing and he used to recite it and he was very proud of himself that he would, but at the time my daughters, his granddaughters, that’s what he would do is would recite that and it was a great insight that she got her freedom but she got her freedom into an icy castle where she was by herself and alone which I found both ironic but also – yeah, if you want full freedom, no rules for me, then I’m free, she had that, but you can only have that with … OK, then you are in a palace of loneliness and that’s what you’re gonna get.
And that is what I think a lot of us have. And I think there’s been philosophers and there’s been astute individuals that have pointed this out that if I want real autonomy, then I can’t actually be in these relationships. I can’t be in these spaces.
I wonder, there’s been a lot of recent reports about how in broad American culture that people sleeping around has been on the decrease, that people’s sex lives have really stopped; or stop’s probably not the right word, but it’s statistically has slowed down and people are wondering why is this? And some are like, well it’s the economy, people don’t have enough money well, people that are in bad relationships who don’t want that. But is it possible that we don’t want the restrictions that physical relationships bring. Is it too costly for us?
Joy Marie Clarkson: This is something, and this is off topic from the book, but I’m just curious about your experience. This is something I’ve thought a lot about actually since moving to London. I moved to London two years ago and before that I did my PhD in a tiny Scottish fishing village. And then before that I was from mountains in Colorado. So it was a big change to go from like, not suburban, American mountains, but still American mountains, to somewhat wild Scotland, to this intensely and densely populated city with people from all over the world. And, one of the things I found was that I was so used to … in American culture, I grew up in a place where you just drove everywhere, right? So, you have this actual, you have your own little frozen palace of freedom in your car, do you know what I mean? Where you can adjust the temperature, where you can adjust the music.
And there’s something I still love about that when I’m back in the States, I enjoy a good car ride. But, it reminds me of, thinking about cultural stories, reminds me of, and I’ve written about this before, but there’s a very famous music video by Lana Del Rey called “Ride.” And it’s all about the American open road, able, you know, able to be in your own little vehicle, free of constraints. And, it’s been interesting for me to think about the … so in in one sense that is a kind of freedom, right? To have freedom of control over your environment, freedom to not be touched or in any way confronted with other people, with their noises, with their bodies, with their smells, with their needs, their slowness or their fastness. But then that there is a different kind of freedom actually that comes from being in the city, right? I’m much more free to experience different foods and cultures and arts. I’m also free from … it’s actually a lot safer for the most part that I don’t drive a car here, right? I’m under less risk. But it’s just made me think about how deeply ingrained, even just in the kind of embodied experience of being a person literally moving through the world, that has been.
I was curious, did you grow up always in New York, or did you have some experience outside New York?
Michael Keller: Yeah, no, we moved here in 1989 and I was nine years old. I grew up mostly in walking culture. We had a car, but we didn’t use it very frequently. And it wasn’t until college that when, I went to college outside of New York City and I got a car for the first time and that was a great experience. There’s a freedom, I can drive wherever I wanna go, but there’s a – this is my little bubble and I can set the climate and my music and no rules for me, except for even the speeding limit.
But as you were talking, it was really interesting, you reminded me of something, Joy, that during Covid in New York City … it really hit our church and the city as a whole, I think we were affected very differently than the rest of America. And we had a lot of people leave the city, and when I would talk to them there was a theme. They would basically say, Michael, I feel like that for this past year or two, I was locked up in my small apartment and I was lonely and I just, I wanna go somewhere where I have space and freedom, and so we’re leaving, we’re moving out of the city.
Well, when Covid was over, people started moving back into the city, I asked people, why did you, why are you moving back, why are you here, why did you move to the city? And they’re like, Well, during Covid, I was out in my big house in the middle of nowhere, and I just felt lonely and there wasn’t anybody around, so I wanted to move to the city where there were people and there was culture, and I just said, wait a second, this is so interesting. Both groups of people looked at their situation and their experiences and they felt lonely, and they moved because they thought they’d be happier – for more freedom, ironically – by coming to a space that the other side had said was the restriction and the problem.
And I feel like there’s a great switcheroo that ended up happening. And when you talk to people they’re like, the ones who moved out, they’re like, I do feel more free. And the ones who moved in, they’re like, I do feel happier and more free.
But for how long? Because I feel like freedom often, when you can’t commit, it just feels like it’s loneliness with better marketing. What’s happening really is you’re exchanging some freedoms for other restrictions, if we’re really honest. Because you’re right, I don’t have a car. That’s a restriction by living in the city. But I have now the freedom experience people I walk by and like literally over there is my cheese shop and over there is my butcher shop. I don’t have to drive twenty, thirty minutes. It’s a two-minute walk.
So there’s certain freedoms. But there’s other freedoms that I don’t have. And I think acknowledging that real life is not about having absolute freedom from all things. Real life is about binding yourself to some things so that you have freedoms in other things. And the real conversation is not, how do you have freedom from all things, but which things that you bind yourself to bring the greater freedoms in life? That’s the real question.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Hmm. I think that’s such a good question. I think it’s actually one that a lot of people have a hard time answering, because they’re not naturally bound to something. Do you know what I mean? I think that maybe something previous generations might have experienced. And by previous generations I mean like a hundred years ago, because I don’t think this is the last fifty years. But I think even for myself, my family moved a lot, which is just a part of my own story, but … so there came a point where I had that realization of, OK, for me to be free or to live a good life, I need to bind myself to something.
And you can bind yourself in various ways, right? There are kind of like gradients of binding. You bind yourself to a physical place, to a geographic place, you bind yourself to a person. Marriage is choosing to not be free to marry anyone in the world because you’ve married one person.
But I think that a lot of people struggle because maybe in a past generation it might have been that the place you would geographically bind yourself to or the church you would geographically bind yourself to was somewhat self-evident. Whereas now we live in such a time of displacement and moving, that it’s hard to know. So I bet you see that a lot in New York. Do you have any advice you would give people about how to choose what to bind themselves to?
Michael Keller: Wow, that’s a big question. In the book what we try to do … I remember, I actually bring up a story about my father … he had a study and whenever the grandkids were visiting, he would bring them back there and he would show them this video of Rafael Méndez where he’s playing Flight of the Bumblebee.
It was this old black and white video that I think he found on YouTube and it’s just, it’s amazing. And if you if you Google that and watch it, how he does it, how skilled he had to be on the trumpet … my father was a trumpet player, so I think he was in awe of what he could do with the trumpet. And we use that as an illustration in the book to show … that, how do you actually get that good on a trumpet?
He actually said, he’s on record in the interview to say the way you do it is scales and then more scales and more. You have to just keep playing and playing and playing and practicing, practicing. What’s happening in that is you’re binding yourself to not watch whatever you want to watch and do whatever you want to do because he’s forcing himself to bind himself to the task of becoming a good trumpet player, but by doing that he has the freedom to make the beauty that’s coming out of his trumpet now. And that leads to a higher good. So by restricting himself from some things, it led to other things.
So to your question, how do you pick, I think one of the questions we need to, hopefully everybody needs to ask themselves, is what losing the freedom of in time and space could potentially bring greater goodness and beauty and freedom out in the world. And a very obvious one would be in art and music. But I think love is a is another thing that I would argue is a great thing to bind yourself to. Like that you brought up the restriction of marrying one person and binding yourself to that person would lead to a greater freedom. But obviously this is a whole cultural debate right now. Other people would say I don’t think that’s that is good. That leads to a restriction and I don’t want that being bound. And so they don’t get married and you see that in the statistics, that there’s more and more people not getting married. So what do you think, Joy?
Joy Marie Clarkson: I guess one thing, and it sounds like we’d both be on this wavelength, would be just to encourage people that binding themselves to something, not just anything, but thoughtfully and prayerfully choosing to bind yourself to things, whether it is in marriage or in a career path or in a place, is a good thing to do, under the right circumstance, right? You don’t need, it doesn’t need to be a kind of ideological, “I must go bind myself to something immediately.” But I think questioning that story that I will feel better and be freer if I’m unbound is the first thing I would want people to know, I think.
And then I think that sometimes I would see in my … I’m a millennial, which apparently is very unfashionable now … But something I saw in a lot of my generation was this kind of huge pressure on what you bound yourself to. Like you needed to figure out what career path exactly God had set for you and that kind of thing.
And I think that something I’ve seen in my own life has been that a lot of choosing what to faithfully bind myself to has been more about just being faithful to what’s in my own life, and what circumstances have been brought about.
So I’ve chosen in this season of my life to bind myself to London. But that wasn’t because I had some great calling to London. It was because I had a job in London, and my husband got a job in London, and so we are choosing in this season to bind ourselves to a church and to a place. Not out of some existential, unmediated knowledge of God’s will for our lives, but because that was what was practical and in front of us, and it was literally the thing that we were called to, right?
I think sometimes people think of calling as some kind of existential thing, but it was literally he was offered a job and I was offered a job and that is a form of calling, right? That is something that’s being said to us.
So I think I would tell people to question the idea that being unbound leads to greater freedom, which I think this chapter does really well. And then to not over existentialize what it means to bind yourself to something, to just kind of respond to what’s in front of you.
Michael Keller: Yeah, I really love that. You could do a whole podcast on how calling is much more earthy and much more mundane, but also beautiful because I think we – when you make it too existential, when you make it too ethereal, too big, it doesn’t, you’re not … what does it mean to be called to your dying parents and you’re having to wash them and take care of them. That’s a high calling even though it’s not glorious, it’s not this grand thing.
But as you were talking, Joy, it made me think, we live in a world … there’s that person, and maybe I’m that person, but I’m gonna talk about this person in the third person, of FOMO, where you leave your options open because you never know if a better option’s gonna come up. When we say “I want to be free” and we don’t choose to bind ourselves, you actually, not to get too philosophical, but we actually are binding ourselves in that moment. You have made a choice. Making no choice, so that you have all choices, is a choice.
And I don’t know if it’s the best one because it leads to so much of loneliness and being paralyzed and frozen in our actions.
So I think there’s something beautiful, as you were saying, we got a job, you got a job, we bound ourselves here. This is it. But acknowledging that is so beautiful and good because it lets us be what we are, not need to be more than that.
It reminds me of, in Lord of the Rings, Galadriel, she’s given the choice of the Ring and she doesn’t take it. But then she has this, almost … of going, OK, it’s OK, I’m gonna stay Galadriel, I’m going to go away into the Grey Havens, and that’s OK. I don’t need to be the emperor supreme and take over the world thing. And that was all right. And I just think there’s something there that’s really beautiful and good.
Joy Marie Clarkson: I think so too. And, from a personal level, I’m really enjoying my … the lines that have currently fallen to me have fallen to me in pleasant places. Do you know what I mean? And there’s something about giving yourself to whatever place and season and callings, even when they’re not glamorous or interesting. London is interesting just because it sounds interesting, but most of my life is not interesting. Do you know what I mean? It’s just living in a city, bumping along with other people on the tube.
Michael Keller: But that’s actually pretty … acknowledging that I think lets other people who are listening maybe realize that’s OK with their world too. You said London sounds glamorous but it’s not. Everybody always thinks the other person’s life is more glamorous than it really is. Instagram makes it worse because it’s always curated and whatnot. But when you talk to anybody in any of their lives, even the people who you think are the most glamorous, it’s just, it’s not, and it’s normal. But what’s so cool about this cultural story is that when we get down and we realize that it’s keeping us from binding ourselves to good things and the best thing might be love, and love by definition means being bound and committed to something, it’s worth losing your freedom to have if the thing that you are binding yourself to in love reciprocates. If it doesn’t, there’s things that you can love that can do a lot of injury. But if it does reciprocate then that boundness leads to more freedom. And that’s OK. And not just OK, that’s good.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Yeah, totally. And I think that’s what by it doesn’t have to be ideological. Sometimes you’ll see people responding to the like, no one’s getting married and no one’s having friendship. Everyone just needs to go out and get married. And I’m like, I don’t … I think that we still have to be thoughtful people with discernment. We still have to think about, who’s a good partner, who’s a godly partner, who is suitable to us. But to get to that point where we don’t have the main cultural narrative as the thing that is driving our unwillingness to bind ourselves I think is helpful.
So I want to ask you a question, which I think is also … I am also in a city so you could probably hear there’s a motorcycle passing by outside … which I think that you do in the book itself. I’ll have some of my own questions for this. But one thing I think is helpful in trying to rewrite these cultural narratives for ourselves or become aware of them and then encompass them. One thing I found really powerful was in your opening you talked about, in your father’s final days, how he would recite the Lord’s Prayer and recite the Psalms and recite the Apostles’ Creed, and how a part of, in the Christian tradition, a part of helping ourselves be reoriented in our story is literally entering into the story of the church and into the story of Christianity. So I want to talk about that later.
But the first thing I want to talk about after is … I think another thing that’s helpful is supplementing the literal stories that we engage with, whether it’s in TV or in literature, that maybe help us rewrite some of those cultural narratives.
So I was curious if you had any stories, be they TV, graphic novel, novels, plays, old, new, that you think are particularly good stories of friendship or of binding yourself to things, that you think people should engage in if they’re thinking about and wanting to be people who do that. I can supply one if you want to think for a moment.
Michael Keller: It’s a great question. Particularly, so I was a college pastor before I planted this church ten years ago so I worked with a lot of college students back between I guess 2009 and 2016, for seven years. And it was an interesting time to be a college pastor because the students who were in college who are eighteen through whatever, from 2009 to … were the first students who actually grew up with a phone. Not a phone like a flip phone, but an iPhone slash screen phone.
And, in my limited experience, I thought that the students that were coming through had a very truncated understanding of how to do conflict. They had a hard time when there was conflict, they would ghost each other. They would just say, Well, OK … because the phones allowed that.
But then they never got to any kind of conclusion, who was actually right or wrong, you could never figure it out because you never had the fight to actually get through that. There were a lot of problems when it came to relationships and friendships and stuff because they hadn’t actually gone through that process.
I felt like a half my job was [to say] You stand here, you stand there. Now, say how you feel. Now what’s your response, what’s your … which conflict is … we always try to avoid it but we don’t realize that, what if you’re the one who’s wrong? How will you ever be shown that you are? How do you ever go through a process of forgiveness and repentance, which is really the basis of change in the Christian worldview, you need to do those things. So I do a hundred percent agree we need to get in those relationships, but they have to be thick enough where we’re willing to go through that.
And the best story, and maybe it’s because I’m a Keller, but I think it’s Frodo and Sam. I mean it’s a great story of … and as you read them over and over and over again, not that everybody has to do that, but that’s what I do, you just keep seeing … at first you’re like, Frodo’s in charge and Sam is the servant. But as you start realizing the relationship and how it evolves and change and how they’re serving each other, and then how they start bearing each other’s burdens very literally, going on a quest and two people … being a friend is not just two people sitting together, it’s people going somewhere together.
You might be able to do that in one place, but anyway I’ll nerd out on that, but I love the story of Frodo and Sam. I think it’s a great friendship story.
Joy Marie Clarkson: I think so. And I think Lord of the Rings actually has quite a few friendship stories woven in with it. I guess it’s significant that the first book is called Fellowship of the Ring, right?
Michael Keller: Tolkien has a lot of thoughts on friendship in relationship to the Battle of Somme that he went through, and the Great War and all the things. He has a lot of thoughts on what it means to be friends. I would acknowledge it’s a very particular view of friendship. There’s a lot of different views of friendship. There’s a very male, war-encapsulated friendships, but it’s still, it’s a type of friendship that’s very valuable.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Absolutely. I’m going to add my, I think this is a complementary one in a weird way, my story I was thinking of. And this may seem like an odd one. But it’s the TV series House, M.D., because I think, at the core of the story, is the friendship between House, this very difficult man, doctor, who basically struggles with addiction, but is brilliant at what he does, and his friend, Wilson, who is also dysfunctional in various ways. But I think the arc of the story is their dedication to each other – which is ambivalent and sometimes unhealthy and whatever – is a part of what gives the story meaning and what gives both their lives meaning.
And I think it’s a good reminder that friendship, and these things we bind ourselves to, can be ambivalent and difficult, but there’s still a value in them and that, in fact, a part of engaging in friendship is being willing to endure that ambivalence and difficulty.
Michael Keller: Yeah. And what’s great about the House one is – and my wife watched that show and so I’d walk by and I’d sometimes see it – he knew he was a difficult person, and so that actually helped in the process of working through the difficult relationship.
I think often we don’t think we’re the difficult person, and what if we actually had the posture of knowing that, OK, that person’s being difficult, but I’m difficult, so we can get through this difficulty together. I think that that’s a really cool insight.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Mm. I think so. Entertaining the possibility that you might be where the problem is, is a good practice in life.
I want to end with the question – and maybe there’s not too much to say about it, or maybe there’s so much to say that we don’t have time for it, as we’re drawing to a close – but that question of, what practical piece of advice you’d give to people trying to re-enter into the Christian story, in some of those practical ways like reading Scripture or telling ourselves the Creed. What does that, what does it look like … you write, in one point, that going to church once a week is not enough. Hearing that story once a week is not going to be enough to re-center ourselves. So what are practical pieces of advice you’d give to people to try to re-narrate their lives?
Michael Keller: Yeah, we’re living a very interesting time with AI giving us lots of knowledge potential, and living with the communication abilities where I’m talking to somebody from London and you’re talking to somebody from New York at the same time. It’s just, it’s beautiful and wonderful. But it can also lead to so much disembodiment because we’re everywhere and nowhere at the same time. And I think that … I’m not a Luddite, we’re obviously using these technologies. I think there’s good things we can use. If again, if all things are good but all things are fallen, then I think we’re allowed to take what’s good from these technologies, but realize that there is also a risk, and problems with disembodiment. So try to put yourself in places where you can be embodied individuals, because that’s how we were made, that’s how we were created.
Really thinking through our createdness … and you already touched on this. I thought it was beautiful saying, Hey, I’m in a physical location in London. I’m here for now, acknowledging that. And I’ve committed to this church, at this place, with this group of friends, for this time. And saying that stuff out loud is so healthy because so often we get stuck in the multiplicity of choices instead of just saying, Nope, this is who I am.
So, I think those are the practices we need to do is, what are our commitments, what are our rhythms, from a Christian worldview is saying, OK, I’m committed to going to church. Why do we go to church? Lots of reasons. The sacraments, the worship, but also the regular reminder of who we are. One of the problems our culture has is it doesn’t know what we were made for. And when you don’t know what you’re made for, you don’t know where you’re … if you don’t know where you’ve come from, you don’t know where you’re gonna go.
But when you know where you’ve come from, how you were made, then you know where you’re going, and you live that in – not just church – it’s people, it’s sacraments, it’s Bible and prayer are other ways to, again, know more about who you are, know more about who God is. And those regular rhythms are just, from my tradition, reformed tradition, we call those the means of grace. The ways to experience grace. They’re very benign. They’re not … there’s a supernatural nature though in the benign. People always talk about supernatural and natural as divides, but I see a very enchanted world that our normal physical world is still all supernatural. I don’t know if we have to make that divide between those two. So living that out, and in very normal everyday human practices, is more beautiful than we usually allow it.
Joy Marie Clarkson: Hmm, I love that. It reminds me of one other … one of the other podcasts in this particular series is on Vermeer and on his depiction of these beautiful ordinary things, mostly that women and people in houses do, whether it’s washing dishes or making bread, and the way that he illuminates …
Michael Keller: Literally.
Joy Clarkson: … literally illuminates it to show this divine light. And I think that’s something along the lines of what you’re saying is, enter these rhythms and these means of grace, but also learn to see the ordinary as a place where God is working and speaking to us.
Michael Keller: Yeah, a place of enchantment. Yeah. I think remembering that and not forgetting that is a practice that, in and of itself, would be a good thing.
Joy Marie Clarkson: I agree. All right, well, thank you so much for speaking to us. This has been just such an enjoyable conversation.
I’m gonna ask you what I ask all of our guests at the end. And I’m gonna remind you that I did ask you this at the beginning, so hopefully you’ll have something mind. What is one thing – it can be a piece of art, a culinary dish, a person, a practice – that reminds you that another life is possible.
Michael Keller: You alluded to this earlier, but I wanna circle back to it. I think … the night that my dad was dying, the last night he was … well, he died a couple of days later, but it was the last night he was conscious, it just struck me that … he would sit with me and say, “I want to recite the Lord’s Prayer, Michael. I want to recite the Apostles’ Creed. Let’s ... read me some Psalms.”
I thought it was to distract him, which it might have been, from some of the pain, but looking back, I really think he was saying those stories … sorry, I’m getting a little emotional. I think he was wanting those stories to be recited because inside those statements of the Lord’s Prayer is a story. Our Father contains an image. His imagination was being moved when you hear, Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name.
He was placing himself into that story by hearing those statements being read. And so as I reflect on it looking back … what reminds me that that another life is possible is when I say these creeds, when I say the prayers, when he … my father knew that he was going home, he knew that that was his story.
What reminds me of another life is possible was that night, as I watched another life being so real to someone that was homesick and ready to go home. And, I want that for myself. I want to be able to say those statements and read the Lord’s Prayer and make that story my story. And I think that lets us know that there’s another life possible.
Joy Clarkson: Thank you so much for that, and for this whole conversation. It’s been a real delight to speak to you.
Michael Keller: Yeah, thanks Joy.