In Defense of Evangelicalism

Jake Meador
Jake Meador is the editor-in-chief of Mere Orthodoxy, an online magazine covering the Christian faith in the public sphere.
Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.
START FREE TRIAL NOWIn Defense of Evangelicalism
A Response to Its Cultured Despisers
By Bonnie Kristian
(Forum Books, 224 pages)
An old saw has it that the definition of an evangelical Christian is anyone who spends time fighting about the definition of an evangelical Christian. Given this, it’s no surprise that the book market is regularly flush with books analyzing the health and influence of American evangelicalism. While it might be tempting for non-evangelicals to regard such books as a curiosity, when a cottage industry of books dedicated to exploring and criticizing one of the largest religious movements in America emerges, these books should be of interest to anyone concerned about the implications.
In recent years, two distinct types of books have become quite common. The first type tends to be highly polemical. They deploy a moralistic critique, arguing that the evangelical movement is corrupt, abusive, or both. At times the argument is paired with a pervasive cynicism in which the sincerity of evangelicals themselves is called into question. Representative volumes here include Kristin Kobes Du Mez’s Jesus and John Wayne, Katherine Stewart’s The Power Worshippers, and Anthea Butler’s White Evangelical Racism.
The second critique tends to build its analysis on sociological data, is generally averse to moralizing critiques, and links its analysis of evangelicalism to broader trends in associational life and religious practice in the United States. Christian Smith’s Why Religion Went Obsolete and Michael Graham, Jim Davis, and Ryan Burge’s The Great Dechurching come to mind as examples.
For many reasons, the conversation about evangelicalism as a movement has largely been dictated by the first set of books rather than the second. This is not necessarily surprising since evangelicals themselves are often highly moralistic and so any critique of them will inherently be shaped by their own moralism. Additionally, many of the polemicists are themselves authors with evangelical backgrounds, which means they often end up using the sermonic tone they learned from evangelicalism to critique evangelicalism.
And yet analyzing a movement as broad, diverse, and underdetermined as evangelicalism via moral critique is fraught. The diversity and breadth of the movement means that virtually every severe moral critique of the movement has ready-made, easily identified counterexamples. And yet explaining this movement is the task Bonnie Kristian, former deputy editor at Christianity Today, set herself in her new book In Defense of Evangelicalism.
Kristian’s purpose is not to sanitize the movement or defend the genuinely indefensible. It is, rather, to press on the many weak points in the moralizer’s critique. Her argument highlights the unjust standards sometimes used to discredit evangelicals, while also offering more sympathetic accounts of the behavior of many evangelical believers.
It is important to be clear about what her book is and what it isn’t. The more sociological critiques of the movement, which I think are more important in terms of understanding the health and future of American evangelicalism, are left largely unanswered. So the upshot of Kristian’s argument is not that everything is well in evangelicalism. She makes no such claim and, in any case, substantiating such a claim, were she to make it, would require engaging with an entirely different genre of critique. That isn’t her purpose.
Her goal, rather, is to offer a spirited defense of a movement toward which she feels an appropriate affection and loyalty. The old word for this is “piety” and, in classical terms, it referred to the duty a son feels toward his father to offer honor, respect, and care, particularly as his father ages. We have expanded the term today to include more relationships, but the root idea is the same: those who have cared for us, provided for us, and sacrificed for us are owed a certain measure of respect and deference.
Happily, Kristian’s pious defense of her evangelical relatives and friends serves another purpose as well. One of the particular evils that is almost unavoidably attached to the broad trend of polemical moralizing is that over time, it tends to erode our sense of our neighbors as being human persons. When we live in the headspace of the moralizing polemicist, we learn to be suspicious of our neighbors and even to fear them or hate them, sometimes without so much as even having a conversation with them. We learn to regard the world as a fundamentally unsafe place.
How we respond to that danger differs from person to person: Some will retreat into a therapeutic bubble in search of personal peace. Others will adopt a militaristic attitude that seeks to subdue or conquer everything in the world that causes them to feel unsafe. The common thread that ties these responses together is the disappearance of human persons from our account of society.
In the 1980s, Wendell Berry wrote a poem to an imagined Siberian woodsman in which he asked, “Who has invented our enmity?” Berry imagined an ordinary husband and father who worked with his hands to care for his family, just as Berry himself did, and saw no reason that he should regard that man as his enemy simply because he happened to live in the Soviet Union. I imagine that if we learned to ask Berry’s question more often – “Who has invented our enmity?” – we would have a healthier public square.
The strength of Kristian’s book is that it encourages us to ask this question, not because evangelicalism is morally faultless or even healthy, but because neighborly love as well as responsible democratic citizenship requires it. In that respect, her book is a great triumph.
—Jake Meador