Community for the Asocial
My search for community led me from Occupy Wall Street and the DSA to a dead end. Then three religious writers changed the way I thought.
Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.
START FREE TRIAL NOWCommunity for the Asocial
My search for community led me from Occupy Wall Street and the DSA to a dead end. Then three religious writers changed the way I thought.
[.smalltext]In order to become myself I must cease to be what I always thought I wanted to be, and in order to find myself I must go out of myself, and in order to live I have to die.
—Thomas Merton[.smalltext]
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Two hundred[.small-caps] and forty years ago a movement arose to liberate humanity from the regnant atomistic mechano-materialist models of selfhood, a movement which conceived of mankind’s development not as determined by inhuman forces from without but as grown from within through the yearnings and passions of each individual’s inimitable will, a vision where the self unfolded organically like a flower (“all is leaf” said Goethe), was disclosed through expressive art and meaningful work, and was above all cultivated through conversation and friendship and love and solidarity and shared struggles for a world where the potential of each could be achieved through participation with the all, a glowing joyful vision of individuality and commonality enriching one another in an ever-virtuous cycle that found expression in the craft-communitarianism of William Morris and the ecstatic republican pluralism of Walt Whitman and the discursive democracy of John Dewey and which peaked in mid-twentieth century New York City when the hunger of Jewish immigrants and their children for ethical and intellectual flourishing (“bildung”), suppressed for centuries, now found orgasmic release through the sidewalk rhapsodies of Leonard Bernstein and the social-democratic strivings of the ILGWU and the raucous streetwise cosmopolitan public culture of Gotham itself, all of which found their way into the souls of my outer-borough parents who in turn transmitted this two-hundred-year-old Quest for the Self to their child, a child whose weeping ashamed struggles for acceptance led him to take up this Quest through politics and protest, through Occupy Wall Street and the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), through scholarship and teaching, all in the hope that by exposing himself to difference and participating in the life of his times and by finding the people and institutions and careers through which he could flourish he could grow into the version of himself the world most needed, he could join the beloved community, if he could only first murder the parts of his self that got in the way.[.article__paragraph--cap]
When I say murder a part of myself, I’m not talking about physical annihilation. I’m talking about cutting out from my brain and body what stands between me and acceptance. The disfigurements in how I think and talk which turn people away. The stuttering shameful confusions that prevent me from understanding myself or others. The inexcusable obliviousness with which I miss social cues, the degrading meltdowns and shutdowns that block me from the Beloved Community. I read the catechism you just read (all 308 words of it) and my heart lifts out from my chest, so right and close does it seem. I splay out my hands and I can almost reach it. But every minute of every day I know there’s something in my blood that’s betraying me, some flaw that keeps me stunted and curdled and useless. Time goes by. I turn thirty, thirty-five. I’m still outside. It’s my fault. I have wasted my life.
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Every day[.small-caps] I hear more and more people about community. I hear from Catholic postliberals and lefty communitarians about our need to belong, our need to oppose modern isolation, our need to build our politics around the fact that man is a “social animal.”[.article__paragraph--cap]
I hear all this and I listen and I agree and I want to scream because I’ve been writing and yearning for community for so long and it did not save me, I practiced community in Occupy Wall Street and the DSA and it did not save me, I believed in the social self and it did not save me. It did not save me because community is not stronger than self-hatred.
What has saved me, at least provisionally, is being able to access a foundational level of love outside of what others can give me. This has not meant becoming a self-possessed monad, the obverse of the other-directed narcissist: if anything it has redoubled my commitment to community. But I see this commitment in terms of what I can offer others through my partial and wounded and holy perspective, and not simply what I might receive from others in terms of acceptance. Because a community made up of frightened conformists is not a community. It is not even an alternative. Only when we learn to accept the wounds and limits that make us, those of ourselves in solitude and those of others in community, can we offer them up as the gifts we and our world need.
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]When I was a child[.small-caps] my parents made me play what they called the “conversation game.” The game was that I would sit in a chair and stay in the chair and look my parents in the eye and not fidget and try to have a conversation. They meant well, but I had a habit of involuntarily rocking in the chair, and one day I rocked backward into a mirror which fell down on my head and cast glass shards through my neck and I had to go to the emergency room (the scars are still there).[.article__paragraph--cap]
I say this only to point out that there was no lack of effort to get me more “social” as a child. Nor was community absent from my ordinary life. We had large family gatherings at home and high holidays full of laughter and warmth. I was shipped to summer camp, leafy and lefty gemeinschafts where grad-school counselors taught us Foucault and everyone danced and sang old labor songs. I remember trying to get away from these gatherings as soon as possible.
My friends were books and buildings. Books and buildings did not ask me questions I didn’t know how to answer, I didn’t need to exhaust myself determining whether books and buildings secretly hated me or not, I didn’t need to feel afraid and then hate myself for being afraid around books or buildings. I would simply read in a corner while other children played, or I’d ride my bicycle down the brownstone streets of Hoboken, or I’d find myself in large crowds inside museums or parks or light-rail station openings, and within the mute anonymous acceptance of these things I would find peace, I would breathe slowly, I would find the security I could never find amidst the more intimate interrogations of family and school.
It wasn’t until college, when I began finding people who shared some of my monomaniacal interests, that I began joining human communities by choice. There was the American Studies club, the College Dems, the Jews who Watched Lost (founding member, happy to say), and above all the Sci-Fi and Fantasy club. These were not people whose interests and postures and judgements were inscrutable to me; these were people who would come up to you frantically monologuing about Banjo-Kazooie out of the blue and I was completely There For It. The first few times this happened I would need to back off and go into a corner and weep from the sheer release of dropping the weight of fear and suspicion I carried into every human encounter, but I’d soon perk up and join my fellow nerds to chomp on stale pizza and talk about Battlestar.[.footnote-link]1[.footnote-link]
By the time I graduated college I had arrived at what I thought were the key ingredients to a happy life: joining communities that shared my interests. And because classrooms and urban spaces were where I first felt accepted in my life (thank you kind teachers!), it seemed obvious that I should go directly to graduate school to study urban history. More specifically, to study the progressive-era city: that era of industrial rust and beaux-art columns when the idea of the Great Community was given full expression through Ashcan-School art and settlement houses and social legislation and the very civic structures (hi NYPL!) that had saved my life in the present.
If I could learn how fragmentation had yielded to community in this past, perhaps I could help accomplish something similar in the present. Thus I began assembling the theoretical tools underpinning the catechism that started this essay, with the lodestars of Dewey, Mumford, and Whitman as my guiding lights (and Marshall Berman and Thomas Bender and Jane Jacobs not far behind). Man was a social animal, democracy was a way of life, and participation was the ends and means of all Good Things. I couldn’t express too much of this in front of my Marxist and Post-structuralist professors or my Extremely Professional classmates (more on this later), but I was able to read my lodestars and weep with abandon after class.
And then I joined the Town Planning Committee of Occupy Wall Street.
After September 11, I remember seeing New Yorkers form impromptu memorials to the fallen and cling to strangers and mourn together and finally realizing the great Arendtian function of public space: as places for individuals to assemble, recognize their shared needs, and cooperate to meet them. Now I saw this happen again in Zuccotti Park: not as a temporary salve but as the basis for civilizational regeneration. Now there was a place in my city, a city run by a billionaire devoted to keeping his consumer-subjects distracted and silent and separated and subdued, where you could come down at any time of the day and go up to a stranger and talk about freedom. Here you could find businessmen and hipsters and homeless people arguing and persuading and feasting on ideas with joyful inarticulate abandon, dropping the scripts they’d been assigned and becoming their own human beings at last. Here was the demos and here was the polis, here was the tongue and blab of conversation, here were the conversations that converted and awakened, conversations that to leave was like an ache until you returned, conversation that was like water, that turned the dead to life. I wanted to help. I wanted … to join a committee.
We on the Planning Committee were responsible for allocating space for a new civilization on one square block. We’d meet in skyscraper lobbies or at McDonald’s tables, make crude maps using beta-versions of Arc-GIS, and figure out how to position the drum circle so it wouldn’t interfere with the food. Then we’d have our proposals voted on (usually down) by the People’s Mic. It was frustrating, it was time-consuming, it was the most alive I’ve ever felt.
The high point of Occupy and possibly my existence took place on October 1, 2011.[.footnote-link]2[.footnote-link] We set out from Zuccotti to march up to City Hall, only to discover that the back of the march hadn’t quite joined us because the drum circlers were drowning out the starting signals. After quieting them down with superb diplomatic finesse I ran to the front of the march and found that it had split – some of us were going up the Brooklyn Bridge walkway, but others had taken the roadway itself. I trot up to the walkway, coward that I am, and I passed through the great cables and stone arches, that great Hegelian synthesis of modernity and tradition rendered in steel and stone, the bridge that Whitman and my ancestors had seen long ago, and I looked down at the roadway and I saw the police surround and arrest my comrades who were shouting out their names so we could look them up in jail, and I saw the helicopters circling over the scene and I felt the pages of history being written with all of our lives, and I came out of the other side and I got in the subway and I travelled back to a ping pong club near the Flatiron building where I met my college friends for my twenty-third birthday party.
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]And then I’d go[.small-caps] back to my work and get yelled at for screwing up again. And I’d go to my classes and notice how calm and professional everyone was, how very much able everyone else was to fold their hands and read the signs and wait their turns and not interrupt, and I wondered why I was such a childish awkward ingrate. (These were not the nerds I was looking for.) And I’d go out alone after class into a world of closed circles and loud conversations and return home without having spoken to a single human. The promise of public life was ringing hollower to me.[.article__paragraph--cap]
And I’d notice that I was getting older and I wasn’t who I wanted to be. I was seeing other people pick a direction, make plans and execute them, whereas for me all was blooming buzzing chaos – I could commit to no plan, decide upon no track. All was confusion, all was regret. So I tried to dive down into my core, trying to find my essence, something I could build a strategy for self-fulfillment upon, but the only thing I had were my interests. Well, following them had gotten me this far, so I guess I would need to find what my Real Interests were. I would write endless lists, endless compendiums of when I felt happiest and most alive, I would take personality tests and life design and life coaching and life envisioning and many many annoying conversations with my therapist, and I would do all this and I would stare at the results, and for a moment I would feel a great elation rush out of my chest – yes, this is what I liked! This is who I was! But then, what? I had no idea.
But other people did.
Before 2013 I was told that my Self was a fictional assemblage of discourses with no center, depth, or autonomy. After 2013 I was told that my Self was a white heteronormative construct. I was being told to give up my naive search for an authentic identity by people with the strongest possible sense of personal branding and professional wherewithal in extremely calm and measured diction in a sector built entirely around external validation.
Well, forget that. If I didn’t know who I was, I sure wasn’t going to let these people tell me. In reaction, for a time, I entirely forsook my quest for identity (during this time I listed my number one pet peeve as “essentialism” for a bachelorette party quiz), saw Trump’s election three months after my wedding in 2016, joined the DSA, and submerged my quest for the self in favor of fighting for Universal Causes: namely, democratic socialism. Adopting the mantle of class warrior had the ego advantage of making me both an Exploited Victim and an Agent of Universal Liberation while still being able to cast everyone else as smug PMC identity-politics warriors.
Eventually I was able to move away from the worst of my reactionary excesses, partly through the need to organize with people different than me: as so often happens, my crusade against “identity politics” was an excuse not to deal with my own woundedness. But that realization would come later. And even in the DSA I could not run away from my anxieties, populated as it was and is by Extremely Professional activists well-versed in well-measured nonprofit speak whose affect and culture seemed so different than mine. They were leftists, like me, but they were also really, really good at, you know, LinkedIn.
The only time I found true solace was when I was teaching. Here in the classroom I could form, in miniature, the kind of communities I always wanted to join: communities of learning where I could help others and be accepted by others (or else I’d fail them, jkjk!). But the classroom was also where I I could forget myself, enter the flow, and concentrate solely on the task of whether my students were learning or not, whether their brows were furrowed or open, whether they participated or kept silent. Some days would go well, some days would not go well, but I never felt judged, never felt like a failure. Only in the classroom did I feel like I could simply exist. And thanks to my earnest devotion to the cause of entering academia as a professor of the humanities, the cause for which I had eagerly sacrificed twenty years of my life, the one role within which I could imagine feeling accepted and fulfilled, I would surely soon find a place within it to oh s---.
In 2020 I graduated on Zoom. There were no jobs. In 2021 I moved out of the glorious metropolis and into the same forsaken suburbs I had tried to escape from. There were no jobs. That year I had my son. In 2022 I got a job and was shortly thereafter fired. In 2023 my father died. I had several breakdowns.
My friends and family, of course, kept me afloat during these years. My wife held me close and carried me through the worst of it. But they could not rewrite the script I had cast for myself: that I had made the wrong choices, that I had created a shining vision of what the good life looked like and I had destroyed any possibility of attaining it, that whatever potential I had was going to die curdled and stunted inside of me. Yes, I knew this was also the fault of capitalism and neoliberalism and possibly Covid and eventually AI, but I also knew that even if there wasn’t a jobs crisis I would always feel like some kind of deviation within this world, I would never stop scouring myself, unless I could find a way to accept myself. I needed to accept myself. But what was there to accept? Who was I, if I was not my interests or talents or “impact”? Who was I, if I was not accepted by a community? Who was I?
All I knew was that I was hurting. So I started there.
And as I burrowed through treatises on depression and anxiety and failure, all the topics verboten in polite academic society, I found my way to a group of religious existentialists who had confronted similar themes on a cosmic scale. These thinkers – Martin Buber, Thomas Merton, Paul Tillich, and others – had seen in their lifetimes the apparent disintegration of every possible source of human meaning. No God or ideology to provide meaning from without: no human nature or essence to give bearing from within. They saw the “free” peoples of the West paper over this void by seeking through consumer hedonism, immersion in social causes, conformity, the bitch-goddess success.
None of this was working. Neither dissolving nor valorizing the self could remove the pain. But these thinkers also recognized that the very fact of our pain, the very fact our of our exhaustion and dismay, was a sign that there was Something There. That woundedness and incompleteness is our existential state: and that rather than escaping or denying or fixing our wounds we should see them as the glowing badges of our humanity, as bridges of empathy toward others, and as the forge that furnishes the unique and needed perspectives that we might offer the world. It is by our wounds that we heal.
Fine words. But who was going to love my wounds?
In my fealty to the “social self” model, I had looked to others for approval through the conventional markers, all the while despising and suppressing the parts of me that seemed insufficient and different and wounded. By distorting myself thus, however, I was deepening my agony and denying the fact of my humanity. Perhaps I had good intentions: perhaps I had hoped that, in time, the raw power of my professionalism would pave the way for me to reveal my wounded full self to my colleagues. Hah. Even if I were to get a tenure-track job this would have been difficult. Now, thanks to the job market, it was impossible.
So I needed another option. I needed something to which I could bring my flawed self and find acceptance, some ground of love on which I could rest, safe from the sea of self-laceration that now engulfed me. Such love could not come from Community as I had come to define it: For such love would always be conditional upon me hiding some part of myself – whether in academia, in activism, or even the sci-fi club. To find love for all of myself would require another source. Perhaps True Self. Perhaps God. But somewhere else.
And so I started with myself. I thought about the people in my life who I loved. If I could love my elderly grandparents, with nothing left to give or contribute, simply by virtue of being selves; if I could love my child softly resting on top of me, regardless of what he had done or failed to do; then I needed to find a way of doing this for myself. So I hugged my child as if he was myself, as if he was the wounded self I had cursed and regretted and tried to smash into a wall so many times before, and I told him “I love you.” And slowly, slowly, I began to see this person, this precious being that I was, as loveable.
A younger me, the part of my self still seeking acceptance through works, would have found this whole exercise in unconditional self-love as hopelessly solipsistic and complacent: one must earn love through good deeds and merit, it would have said. And to that younger self I lovingly say: I understand why you say this, I forgive you, and for the love of god please shut the hell up.
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Encountering[.small-caps] this new form of love changed the way I understood community.[.article__paragraph--cap]
I still see the Great Community – a world where each soul’s individuality enriches the commonweal and is in turn enriched by it – as the greatest cause to which we can devote ourselves. But we cannot leverage our individuality on behalf of the community if we suppress our individuality for the sake of participation. Nor can we expect communities to do the hard work of recovering and loving our full individuality for us. No: we must gain a non-social source of love on behalf of our full selves, if we are to gain the courage needed to offer that full self on behalf of others. As Thomas Merton wrote in his Contemplation in a World of Action, “The alienated man cannot love.” “He has nothing to give. Nothing is his. The lover is able to give himself completely to another precisely because he is his own to give. He is not alienated. He has an identity. He knows what is his to surrender.”
Community thus takes on a different role for me: not as the terrain of existential validation, but as a contingent project for me to engage in and build up. For having encountered a greater love in solitude, I need no longer hate others – or myself – for failing to achieve that love in public. I can see others as they are – as my brothers and sisters in woundedness – and not as my judges. And thus I can work alongside our brothers and sisters, unthreatened by their failure to render what was never theirs to give, and build towards the Great Community we need. Here Henri Nouwen rang true: “Community is not loneliness grabbing onto loneliness: ‘I’m so lonely; you’re so lonely. Please stay awhile!’ ... No, community is solitude greeting solitude: ‘I am the beloved; you are the beloved. Together we can build a home.’”
Above all, I see the challenges of the modern world in a new light. I had formerly looked to community as the great salve to modern isolation. Liberal capitalist modernity: it’s isolating! This, of course, is a charge that has been made by many postliberals on the left and right. It’s a charge I’ve made myself. But liberal capitalist modernity does this not only by removing us from outside community, but removing us from the community closest to us: the community of ourselves. We are, ourselves, an undiscovered country of weakness and meaning and insight. But we live in a society that denies this, that compels us to wrap ourselves in the single abstract standard of That Which is Valued by the external world – goods and jobs and titles and accomplishments – while hiding all that is shameful and distinctive and unknowable. We alienate ourselves. And in hiding our individuality and suppressing our needs, we wind up creating partial communities based on falsehood and shame, communities that do not summon what is best and most valuable out of their members.
But there is another possibility. We can make a world where the full diverse ecosystem of human cognition and affects and gifts and yearnings can be cultivated together and enriched together, where individuality and community dance together, where everyone feels at home. We can revive the Romantic dream. Because all that stuff about the Beloved Community: I still want it. It’s still real. But now I know that a community is beloved only when all of its members consider themselves beloved: not by others, not by community, but by themselves and by God.
And so I find myself taking up again the standard of Whitman: the poet not just of city and community, but of the doubtful and broken and despairing individuals (of whom Whitman was one) who nonetheless found a way to turn their wounds into the words they might wield against their demons:
I will confront these shows of the day and night,
I will know if I am to be less than they,
I will see if I am not as majestic as they,
I will see if I am not as subtle and real as they,
I will see if I am to be less generous than they,
I will see if I have no meaning, while the houses and ships have
meaning,
I will see if the fishes and birds are to be enough for themselves,
and I am not to be enough for myself.
I’m still not totally enough for myself. I’m still not free of regrets and insecurity. And I’m still not totally sure what kind of self I am. But I do know, as I hold my son lying softly on my stomach, that he and I are beloved. For a long time I entrusted that task to other people. Now I don’t.