You have

{{score}}
free articles remaining.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.

Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.

START FREE TRIAL NOW

Field Notes from an Extinction

December 15, 2026

‍

‍

A Novel

By Eoghan Walls

(Seven Stories Press,

288 pages)

When Jonathan Swift penned “A Modest Proposal” in 1729, his purpose was to shock the British elites into action. Incensed by the “economically necessary” yet extractive policies that left his native Ireland in poverty, he hoped to offer a reductio ad absurdum that would render ridiculous such explanations for inaction: the best way to prevent “the children of poor people in Ireland from being a burden on their parents or country and for making them beneficial to the publick,” he wrote, would be to sell them as food. (Yes, that disgust you are now feeling was his desired effect.) The pamphlet drew the outrage that Swift desired from his audience, but it did not achieve the economic reforms that he had hoped for, and the poverty in Ireland grew worse.

Eoghan Walls’s novel Field Notes from an Extinction has no hoped-for economic reforms motivating it (at least none that Walls makes explicit), but it is similarly convicting. Set over one hundred years after the publication of Swift’s pamphlet, it takes place two hundred miles north of Dublin on a small rock known as Tor Mor off the northernmost tip of Ireland, three thousand feet from the island of Inishtrahull. Ignatius Green, an “ornithologist and redeemed öologist,” has been sent to Tor Mor by the Royal Society and sponsored by Sir Walpole Phillip of Barrow to observe and document the “last surviving colony of Pinguinus impennis, commonly known as the Garefowl or Great Auk.” As its title suggests, the novel is his field notes.

Ignatius Green, or Ig, as he calls himself, is a sympathetic narrator. His commitment to his study is obvious from the precision of his notes. But his interest in the garefowl is more than coldly scientific. His affection for the birds is clear, as he has named each of them perfectly: the four nesting couples – Othello and Desdemona, Antony and Cleopatra, Canute and Boadicea, and Macbeth and Lady Macbeth – and the two single males – Lear and Falstaff. The latter two “remain close enough to attempt wooing the other females, occasionally causing a joust. . . . No lethal blow is ever struck; they are cautious in both attempted adultery and violence.”

Trouble arrives on Tor Mor when the monthly shipment of goods brought to Ig by the islanders of Inishtrahull and their reckless leader, Liam McGonigle, has been “interfered with” (some goods have been stolen). More disturbingly, hidden away in the shipment is a small, malnourished girl with a note pinned to her torn and spoiled dress. Addressed to “Ignashus Green,” it instructs him to care for the child. It is signed “The Canniball Aisling O’Leary” [sic]. Ig suspects foul play from the islanders or from a dockhand, but he is now forced to choose between his precious birds and the child.

His frustrations at the difficulty of this choice are evident in his field notes. He has always viewed the islanders with disdain – “skinny monkey youths, spluttering under tarpaulins” – but now he is forced to encounter a real live Irish child face to face, and despite her grime and snotty nose, he begins to feel compassion toward her. The bond that grows between Ig and the girl is the subject of much of the novel.

Eoghan Walls is first and foremost a poet, and his lyrical and linguistic abilities are evident on every page. His characters are at times funny, at times strange, and at times horrific, but they are always believable. His ambition for his novel, however, is not merely to document a relationship formed between an ornithologist and an impoverished Irish girl. Ig writes in the cover letter of his field notes that “What the men of Inishtrahull have done . . . to the birds . . . is a deliberate act of extinction.” But Walls knows that Ig’s field notes describe more than one attempted extinction. As Ig and the girl make their way to the Irish mainland, they are met with an almost post-apocalyptic scene. This is the start of the famine, an Gorta Mór, in which the extractive economic policies that Swift wrote against – and a potato blight – have led to widespread starvation.

At times, it feels as though Walls’s ambition for his novel is too great. He is certainly at his strongest when his characters are confined on Tor Mor. As Ig sees the poverty and starvation of the Irish, it is unclear whether his feelings toward them have been changed at all. One thing is certain though: his compassion and affection for the girl. This love for the innocence of a child is the power of both Walls’s and Swift’s message. As G. K. Chesterton once wrote:

I begin with a little girl’s hair. That I know is a good thing at any rate. Whatever else is evil, the pride of a good mother in the beauty of her daughter is good. It is one of those adamantine tendernesses which are the touchstones of every age and race. If other things are against it, other things must go down. If landlords and laws and sciences are against it, landlords and laws and sciences must go down. With the red hair of one she-urchin in the gutter I will set fire to all modern civilization.

—Alan Koppschall

Let us know what you think

Selected letters to the editor are published in each magazine issue.