Can These Bones Live?
Searching for remains of migrants along the Arizona–Mexico border, I remembered the vision of Ezekiel.
Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.
START FREE TRIAL NOWCan These Bones Live?
Searching for remains of migrants along the Arizona–Mexico border, I remembered the vision of Ezekiel.
[.smalltext]Y yo acá de este lado
Muriendo, muriendo de dolor
—Cuco Sánchez, “Una Cerca en Mi Camino”[.smalltext]
[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Early in the fall[.small-caps] of 2024, my friend Jaret Ornelas invited me to join him and a group of his fellow Jesuits heading to the Arizona–Mexico border to search for and document the remains of migrants. That December, less than three hours from my hometown, we would backpack into a desert valley to walk in imperfect grids for three days, yards between our shoulders, with our eyes roving over the desert floor. We would have to carry all of our water. If we found remains – mostly bones were expected – we would stop the line, pray, mark the coordinates, hang thin, pink hi-vis tape, photograph the scene, and then pray again. The photographs were essential, however unseemly they might feel.[.article__paragraph--cap]
We could not bury the remains ourselves. We could not take them to anyone looking for them, if anyone still was. Our coordinates and pictures would be sent to the sheriff’s office so that the remains could be recovered, analyzed, and, hopefully, though rarely, identified and repatriated. Long unidentified remains have had a variety of fates: cremation and scattering without record, burial under “John” or “Jane Doe,” or continued waiting in a medical examiner’s office. James Holeman, the founder of Battalion Search and Rescue, the organization we would be partnering with, said that in certain counties, after a year, he had revisited reported sites, and found the bones remained unrecovered. Besides helping officials locate the bones, the photographs also told a concrete story that was less easily ignored. A story as concrete as a sun-bleached femur. The lagging counties might hurry if the pictures showed up in the news.
Even in the midst of the alternation between numb busyness and frantic stress that graduate school brings, I felt connected to the work. For eighteen years I had lived largely ignorant of the border. It was something to have an opinion about. When the checkpoint line was too long, it was something that my school friends complained took forever to cross. Six years later, my awareness had grown while my experience had not. I felt like I was neglecting a duty. This was my backyard; I should know what was happening there.
After I told my dad, he asked, not unkindly, “What good does that do?” As a surgeon, he is painfully aware of the limits of human help. I offered a faltering response, but I remembered his question throughout the trip and afterward. The journey would be arduous and expensive, given the travel. The bones often remain anonymous, and there are many living migrants in sore need of help. Shouldn’t we focus on the living? Did Jesus not say, “Let the dead bury their dead …”? Despite these doubts, my reservations were outpaced by some instinct. I knew this trip would make me confront what I had long been ignoring before I knew exactly how.
[.small-caps]It was not long[.small-caps] after I arrived at James and his partner Abby’s house in Ajo, Arizona, that the place was abuzz with nervous preparation. Some of the Jesuits had stayed there overnight, and I caught up with some and was introduced to others in between checking and rechecking the packing list, picking out a hi-vis hat and vest, and figuring out the water bladder I was borrowing. James had emphasized that every ounce counted. I debated bringing an extra pair of socks, eventually leaving them behind. Whether for comfort or caution, being overprepared would be too much of a luxury on this trip. I packed and repacked my backpack, trying to balance the heavy jug of water.
Two pickup trucks took the fifteen or so of us to the start of the ten-mile trek into the valley we would be canvassing. They were driven by locals involved in the border-aid nonprofit world. One man filled up barrels of water for thirsty migrants; sometimes the barrels were found later, shot through with bullet holes. After over half an hour, we got out and were given trekking poles and walkie-talkies. Following a short introduction to both, we turned without ceremony toward the desert and started walking.
The landscape, hostile as it was, reminded me of my desert home. Tan, sandy dirt, peppered with rocks in every direction, broken up by hardy chaparral and perpetually dead-looking grass. Saguaros stood over everything, only the tops of the dark mountains in the distance looming above them. The sky stretched wide and high, bright blue and cloudless. Even in December the heat was punishing, and the sun’s light seemed eternal, until the vibrant pinks and oranges of the sunset eventually reminded us otherwise.
Soon, we started seeing signs of migrants: abandoned carpet shoes worn to prevent footprints, broken cellphones, water bottles covered with dark tape to prevent eye-catching glare, discarded backpacks half-buried in sand. It was a long walk, and I chatted with the diverse group of priests, deacons, and priests-in-formation. They say that when you’ve met one Jesuit, you’ve met one Jesuit. Many came from different countries, and most of the Americans were from different states. One had a PhD in literature; another was an engineer. Some were cyclists who had ridden for hundreds of miles; others were more bookish, apprehensive of the mileage.
But they looked after one another. Those who were more capable carried more, and those who were less capable asked for help. Halfway through the hike out, my stomach dropped as I realized that my water bladder had been slowly leaking for miles because I had shut it incorrectly. I couldn’t help feeling the gravity of the exact mistake that I had been warned about back in Ajo. Now, after my jug ran out, whatever water I drank would have been carried by someone else. Our dependency on each other sank in to a new level, and I realized this group of brothers was also looking after me.
We made it to camp and had our first Mass in the desert that night. With an overturned milk crate as an altar and a host of flashlights to see, we worshiped under the stars. The next morning, we rose early to take advantage of all the daylight we could. As we prepared to sweep the desert in grids, Jaret reminded us of what to look for and where. In the desert, corpses and carcasses become white bones very quickly. The shock of white stands out amid the abundant tans, beiges, and dark browns of the landscape. Bones are often carried away by the sporadic rains, so riverbeds demanded extra attention. Finally, we should also try to imagine the decisions of the desperate. If you were dying of thirst in the heat or of exposure in the cold, where would you lie down? In which small shade or nook would you try to take shelter?
Our first point of business was to revisit a site that James had found last year to double-check if the sheriffs had recovered the remains. Thankfully, there was nothing left at the site. Still, Jaret told us that it was best practice to sweep in a circle around the site in case weather or animals had moved something. We spread out, and I started checking along a small riverbed with some clusters of bushes. Soon, I found a cellphone. This was not something we reported over the walkies – apparently it was common to find discarded phones on the desert floor – but something felt deeply wrong. Whose phone was this? Don’t they need it? It felt too human for a place this remote.
I continued to search along the riverbed and, around a bush, something white stuck out to me. I hurried over and saw the curve of a rib sticking out of the sand. The jolt from the phone was doubled, and tears came to my eyes as I reeled from the realization that this was once a person. I called it in, and soon Jaret came over and verified it was most likely human. We went through the protocol: mark the spot on our navigation app, hang hi-vis tape, take pictures, and then we prayed. Jaret and James had both mentioned that finding someone’s remains is always a complicated feeling. Heartbreak at the death mixes with relief and hope that they might be returned to loved ones.
I didn’t find any more remains for the rest of the trip. Strangely, even with the morbid character of the mission, most of the experience was hiking through a beautiful, if harsh, landscape with people I enjoyed being around. As you swiveled your head and tried to see white, your mind would wander, sometimes into the experiences of the people we were looking for and sometimes into the mundane. As my feet grew sore or I grew thirsty or one of our members hurt an ankle, the realization of how horrific it would be to die in the desert would hit me over the head. Other times, when I was lost in idle thought or had a song stuck in my head, I would be brought back to reality by something called over the walkies: “Need a moment for water,” or “Let’s stop for a bathroom break,” or “I think I found a skull.” Amidst the camaraderie of a shared mission and the stark beauty of the landscape, the brokenness of the world confronted us sporadically but undeniably.
[.small-caps]One evening we shared[.small-caps] how we were making sense of the experience. Somehow in the dark, the feelings didn’t feel as overwhelming. We voiced the bleak reality we were encountering, and I remember Joshua, a Jesuit from Australia, sharing his anger – anger that we had to do this work at all. I struggled to know what exactly I was feeling. Sitting on the cool sand and listening, I realized I didn’t know what to make of it all. Conflicting emotions and thoughts rushed through me at the same time, or I felt detached, at a distance. At the center of my confusion was my father’s question. I believed wholeheartedly that what we were doing was good, but I didn’t know how to articulate why. The sheer finality of death made so many of the theological concepts I knew feel flimsier. What good was all my studying if it had nothing to say to this? As I wrestled with these questions, Abby, James’s partner, shared words that Jaret had told her when they last worked together: “Death does not have the final say.” Somehow, at least for the remainder of the trip, these words were enough of an answer for me. But I still doubted.
After death, the actions of the living seem meaningless. Bodies do not seem like the people they once were, and the rituals that surround them can feel like desperate grasping for what is forever lost. To find someone’s remains was to find them too late. There was no way to remember hard enough for their names not to be forgotten. There was no way to get to them in time, to change those last lonely moments, to save them from a horrific death by exposure, dehydration, or a snake’s bite. And yet, we found ourselves returning to the phrase “death does not have the final say.”
Practically speaking, what we were doing was a waste of resources that could be better used elsewhere. But those words, “death does not have the final say,” resisted this sort of calculation. They gestured to another way of making sense of it all that was both obvious and profound. Obvious because we believed the Christian story which tells of resurrection, death’s total refutation. Profound because this familiar story was made newly urgent and real without changing a word. In this context, the language of Christianity in our Masses, prayers, and conversations was made more tangible just as the brute reality of the experience gained a spiritual depth beyond what immediately confronted us. Almost exactly a year after the trip, I was confronted with another valley of dry bones, this time in my Old Testament class. I was dumbfounded that Ezekiel’s powerful vision had not come to mind in the months after our mission in the desert, but once it had, I couldn’t think of the two valleys apart.
[.small-caps]Ezekiel prophesied a calamity[.small-caps] and saw it come to pass: “An end! The end has come upon the four corners of the land” (Ezek. 7:2). In 597 BC, the Babylonian Empire successfully laid siege to Jerusalem, capturing it and exiling a significant portion of the ruling class and craftsmen. Then, a decade later, in 587 BC, King Zedekiah rebelled against Babylonian rule, and the city was laid under siege for a second time. After months and months of starvation, the walls were finally breached, and Jerusalem was captured yet again. Babylon’s vengeance on the annoyingly defiant kingdom was cruelly calculated as much as it was fueled by wrath. There would not be a third rebellion.
After the slow horror of the siege, the starving inhabitants faced a frenzy of bloodshed and destruction. Jerusalem was pillaged and burned as the conquerors killed men, women, and children indiscriminately. But even this did not satisfy Babylon’s wrath nor Ezekiel’s prophecy of catastrophe. The Babylonians would not stop at destroying the walls, the city, or the lives of their enemies; the rebels’ God must die too. Over four hundred years after Solomon’s temple was constructed, the Babylonian army razed it to the ground.
It is difficult to overstate the importance of the Temple to the Israelites. Set on a high point of Jerusalem, a city on a hill, the Temple was the pinnacle of Israelite life and culture. The Israelites’ religious imagination flowed to and from the mysterious center of the imposing building, the Holy of Holies, where God was thought to dwell. The desecration and destruction of the Temple, then, was surely interpreted as the end of God’s presence to the Israelites. Either God was defeated, or God had abandoned them.
After the destruction of the Temple, the majority of Jerusalem’s inhabitants were exiled to Babylon, leaving only “some of the poorest people of the land to be vinedressers and tillers of the soil” (Jer. 52:16). For those deported, two of the most central signs of God’s sovereignty and Israel’s identity were now taken away. Where was God if the Temple was destroyed? Who were God’s people if they were not in the land God promised them? Now all that remained were songs, rituals, and traditions bereft of the context in which they were once meaningful. As the psalmist asked, “How could we sing the Lord’s song in a foreign land?”
Babylon’s goal was despair. A people with nothing to live for might finally try to just survive. To increase the despair, to make its enemies hang up their harps, the empire did not stop at violence toward the living. After Ezekiel’s prophecy comes to pass, he is brought out “by the spirit of the Lord” to a mass grave. This mound of bones is not a benign representation of all who had died, nor is it only a metaphor. In the ancient Near East, according to Old Testament scholar F. Charles Fensham, “one of the severest penalties … is to die and not to be honored after death by a proper burial.” Old Babylonian boundary stones and Neo-Assyrian treaties both attest to improper burial as punishment for breaking with the terms of an agreement. A contemporary of Babylon’s king Nebuchadnezzar II, the Assyrian king Ashurbanipal boasted, “I fed their hacked flesh to the dogs, pigs, jackals, vultures, the birds of the heaven, and the fish of the deep. . . . I took their bones to Assyria, thereby condemning their ghosts to restlessness.” Even the dead faced exile. Piles of exposed bones were war trophies to bring home for the kings of the dominating Near Eastern empires and monuments of despair for the subjugated vassals they deported.
[.small-caps]Migrants have crossed[.small-caps] the United States–Mexico border ever since it was established. People move for many reasons. In the nineties, however, movement became increasingly restricted, and the Border Patrol’s technology and tactics started to resemble those of a military force. After September 11, 2001, this process progressed rapidly. The sudden solidification of a barrier that had been previously permeable tore apart trade routes, communities, and families alike. But despite the restrictions, thousands of people continued to cross all along the thousands of miles of border.
The plan for slowing this movement was intuitive: with plenty of border and limited patrol, guard the places people are most likely to cross. Cities, towns, and gentle terrain would be heavily monitored while ragged mountains, wide rivers, and barren deserts would do the work of a wall. Prevention Through Deterrence (PTD). After its first implementation in 1993, the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) eventually came to adopt this policy as a nationwide standard. The reasons to cross became all the more intense as the difficulty of crossing increased, however. While there seemed to be no significant change to the number of people crossing, the number who died while crossing did increase. The weaponization of the landscape, however much it deterred, did not stop everyone from attempting the risky journey. This has led to a situation where PTD’s effectiveness hinges on the deadliness of the border.
Deterrence relies on horror. The bleaker the stories migrants’ families hear, the more effective the deterrence. And so, the inaction of the INS in recovering remains facilitates strategic goals whether or not it itself is strategic. To leave bones to be forgotten and to prevent their recovery by families sends the clear message that those who cross will not face just death, but erasure and indignity.
[.small-caps]The fear of death’s finality[.small-caps] wasn’t lost on Ezekiel: “Then he said to me, ‘Mortal, these bones are the whole house of Israel. They say, “Our bones are dried up, and our hope is lost; we are cut off completely”’” (Ezek. 37:11). This fear seems to remain in part even after Ezekiel has prophesied bones joined together, prophesied flesh and skin upon them, and prophesied the ruach, the breath or spirit, to inspire the recreated bodies. It comes after the Lord’s question which Ezekiel cannot answer, “‘Mortal, can these bones live?’ I answered, ‘O Lord God, you know’” (37:3). Even resurrected, the bones of Israel doubt. But the Lord God promises hope in spite of death. “And you shall know that I am the Lord, when I open your graves, and bring you up from your graves, O my people. I will put my spirit within you, and you shall live, and I will place you on your own soil” (37:13–14).
This is a prophecy that tells of a God who can never come too late and a God who remembers, because God pronounces that death doesn’t have the final say. These are dangerous words. They undermine every kingdom founded on the power of death. Unlike Israel’s doomed rebellions, this confrontation doesn’t match sword for sword. Instead, this confrontation is on the level of narrative, matching story for story. Stories are how we make sense of the world, and so they determine much of what we think of as real. History has to be told, science must be interpreted, and borders need to be drawn.
Death precedes every resurrection, and so just as every life must face the question of death, every death now faces the question of new, unending life. Lining the edges of a mass grave is the wild and defiant promise that the story does not end here. In burial we question death’s word, but it is the Lord who silences it forever. “Oh death, where is thy sting? Oh grave, where is thy victory?” can only be asked because “Christ is risen from the dead, trampling down death by death, and on those in the tombs bestowing life!”
Whether or not one believes that in refusing burial to the dead, empires are “condemning their ghosts to restlessness,” the attempt at recovery and repatriation, even if unsuccessful, tells a story. It disturbs the narrative reality of the border and the “mass open grave” in the Sonoran Desert. This ministry offers a counternarrative that only makes sense if we can hope for resurrection. If death is final, our work does no lasting good, and the tragic end of the migrants’ lives will always cry out from the ground louder than our attempts to remember them. If Ezekiel’s prophecy means anything, however, then no matter how seemingly insignificant, this quiet work is a way of proclaiming a story, a reality, where the good done isn’t just to bones or to the living that remember them, but to God’s people who will be raised again on the last day. The bones’ purpose is now God’s purpose. When we find remains, we not only find the dead, but the sacred.
For eighteen years I lived a life almost entirely ignorant of the border while being close enough to see it. My ignorance was not merely incidental. The less death’s power is noticed, the more freely it can act. The ministry of recovery and burial, then, does not have to do God’s work of resurrection. Instead, in its seeming wastefulness, it need only ask again and again, “Can these bones live?”
This question remained for Ezekiel just as it remains for us, since what was promised has not yet come to pass. We await the day when bone shall be joined to bone, flesh shall come upon them, skin shall cover them, and God’s spirit be breathed into them. We do not wait idly, though. We make straight in the desert a highway for our God by proclaiming through our ministry that life, not death, has the final say. We remember that the true ending of everyone’s story is a new beginning, resurrection, so that when we see a mass grave, horror is not all that we find. As we walk through the valley of dry bones, we fear no evil, for when we listen closely, we hear a sudden noise, a rattling.