You have

{{score}}
free articles remaining.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.

Try 3 months of unlimited access. Start your FREE TRIAL today. Cancel anytime.

START FREE TRIAL NOW
Book Excerpt

What Makes a Good Children’s Book?

By treating the child’s experience with dignity and compassion, the children’s writer can often get to the very essence of human experience.

November 24, 2026

‍

[.article__paragraph--cap][.small-caps]Fiction is that rare place[.small-caps] where the adult and child can meet as equals. Equals, but not the same: It is true that adults know many things that children do not. But it is also true that we have forgotten many of the things kids know – not just about what it is like to be a kid, but about the world we all share.[.article__paragraph--cap]

Many adults see children as stupider and less sophisticated versions of themselves. Kids, they think, are future adults – little kids are the worst, but they get smarter as they get older, until one day, thank god, they’re grown up.

When my son was about to turn two, strangers would offer condolences. There’s a collective cultural dread of toddlers, who get described more like animals than people. Kids in their “terrible twos,” I was warned, are illogical, unregulated, and feral. “Good luck,” people would say. “He’ll grow out of it.”

I’m lucky: My son is a very easygoing kid. But I remember the first tantrum he threw for me. He was standing by our front door and asked to go outside. So I opened the door and grabbed his shoes. But as soon as he stepped onto the porch, he pointed back into the house.

“Inside,” he said.

“OK,” I said. I picked him up and brought him inside.

But as soon as I shut the front door, he pointed outside.

“Outside!” he said.

You know where this is going. We went back and forth, inside and outside, again and again. He got more frustrated. And I got more frustrated. Eventually he wound up straddling the threshold of our house, sobbing. When I tried to comfort him, he screamed at me. “You go wherever you want!” I said. He just got madder. I felt trapped, convinced he’d concocted the whole episode as a pretext to unleash his rage at me. It was ridiculous. I consoled myself with the thought that he was just being a toddler.

But later I kept thinking about him wailing at our front door, one foot inside, one foot outside. His misery wasn’t unreasonable, or trivial, or silly. My son was experiencing the agony of wanting two things that were impossible to have at the same time. What a fundamentally human sorrow! My son wasn’t being a toddler; he was being a person. Adults may not walk around howling, but that same pain rages within us. In that moment, as a father, I was powerless to solve my son’s problem. I told him he could go wherever he wanted, but of course I was wrong. To be where he wanted was impossible.

Impossibility, paradox, anguish – this is the stuff of fiction. (Not to mention that stories are the only reliable way I’ve found to occupy two places at once.) By treating the child’s experience with dignity and compassion, the children’s writer can often get to the very essence of human experience.

And what are “childish enthusiasms” but the ability to see the world with the freshness and wonder that literature requires? The child who stares and marvels at the workings of a garbage truck sees the garbage truck better than adults do. The kid who breathlessly recounts horse facts, who finds it overwhelming that such an amazing creature actually exists, is correct.

My son loves the moon. He never forgets to look for it, and he points it out to me every night as soon as it gets dark, “Hey, the moon.” He watches the moon change. He delights in its beauty. The moon gives him real joy. In this way he is like a lot of other three-year-olds and unlike most adults, excepting the poets and astronomers who, like my son, remind us to look up at the sky.

Anyone who spends time with children knows that they ask questions – big questions that are hard for us to answer. What is love? Does god have a face? Why do we dream? What happens after we die? Why do people get sick? Do trees have feelings? Why do we have to follow rules? Do dogs find things funny? Why do people fight wars? How do our brains work? Why is my friend nice to me one day and mean the next? Why do I have to clean my room? These are many of the same questions that writers, for centuries, have been asking. The child and the writer are both engaged in the same huge task: trying to figure out what it means to be a person in the world. The children’s writer must always respect the child. It is our job to approach the reader in a spirit of play and fellow feeling.

On the other hand, the adults who read books to kids – parents, teachers, librarians, caregivers – are authority figures. Their relationship to children is, most of the time, governed by a different set of responsibilities. So for these adults, sharing a story with a child is an opportunity for hierarchies to be temporarily abandoned, even joyously inverted: If you’ve read good books to kids, you’ve probably been surprised when they noticed a detail in the pictures that you didn’t see, or been humbled when they understood something about the story you couldn’t. That’s because children tend to be better readers – more open-minded, more diligent, and more passionate – than adults. (No offense.)

Kids are certainly more willing to engage deeply with stories that demand the reader’s active participation, books we might call art fiction or literary fiction. This surprises a lot of adults, who assume that if something is difficult for a grown-up, it’ll be much harder for a child. But that’s not true for climbing trees or coming up with good names for pets, and it’s not true for reading. The genius of children is liberating, making possible new and ambitious fictions. Here is the author Margaret Wise Brown describing a five-year-old:

When a child reaches the age of five he is the sum total of all his younger experiences and discoveries in a brand new world. He carries with him the two-year-old’s delight in sheer sound and pounding rhythms and the glamor of the two-year-old’s own small self; the three-year-old’s humor and love of pattern, and his pleasure in the familiar sights of his own world; the four-year-old’s further joining of sound and pattern with rhythm and content, and the four-year-old’s first playful flights into the humor of the incongruous things that he just knows enough to know are not true; and finally the five-year-old’s own keen humor and penetrating observation of the world around him, the careful watching of his own eyes and ears, the keenness of his nose and the sensitiveness of his touch, and the fine and vivid imagery of his own language.

Margaret Wise Brown was one of the twentieth century’s great American writers, the author of more than one hundred picture books for children. I don’t mean that she was a great American writer for adults who also wrote books for kids. She was a children’s writer. More specifically, she was a picture book writer, maybe the first great picture book writer, in the sense that she did not illustrate her own texts but nevertheless mastered the picture book’s peculiar form.

Although throughout her short life she worried that she wasn’t a real writer, Brown was a major poet who discovered in the picture book a perfect vessel for her talents, and in children the ideal audience for the ambitious and often deeply strange stories she wanted to tell. For Brown, a lover of James Joyce and Virginia Woolf, it was the child who is most alive to the possibilities of literature:

Rhythm is important to him. Images are important, and even the abstract sound of words. That is what is so exciting about writing for fives. Here is an audience sensitive to the sheer elements of the English language. Here is the playful audience of James Joyce and Edith Sitwell and Gertrude Stein, the audience of Virginia Woolf and Swinburne and the King James version of the Bible. Translate their playfulness and serious use of the sheer elements of language into the terms and understandings of a five-year-old and you have as intelligent an audience in rhythm and sound as the maddest poet’s heart could desire. This is the discovery Lewis Carroll made and the anonymous authors of the old nursery rhymes. Hey diddle diddle the cat and the fiddle... A rose is a rose is a rose...

Both of the foregoing passages by Brown come from an essay called “Writing for Five-Year-Olds,” written in the late 1930s while Brown was studying at the Bureau of Educational Experiments, better known as Bank Street, which is a shorter but sadly much less cool name. Brown had moved to New York to become a writer but was having trouble getting published, or even producing work she liked. After working as a salesgirl at a department store and as a nanny to a rich family, she decided to apply to Bank Street’s Cooperative School for Student Teachers. Brown liked kids. She was going to be a teacher.

Bank Street was a laboratory school founded by the pioneering theorist Lucy Sprague Mitchell “to study children – to discover what kind of environment best suits their learning and growth, then create that environment and train adults to maintain it.” In addition to child development, there was coursework in subjects like dance, writing, and improvisational theater. It was a hotbed of progressive educational theories, an exciting place for a young iconoclast like Margaret Wise Brown to study.

Brown’s instructors at Bank Street were unanimous about her future as a classroom teacher: It was bleak. By all accounts Brown was kind of a shirker, active in class discussions but bad at turning in homework. Her evaluations say things like “should work more” and “Can’t place her. Written work fair” and “much of the time Miss Brown seems to be in a daydream” and “report on endocrine system: missing” and “seemed to contribute a somewhat disorganizing influence to the class” and “of very little help in practical situations” and “work with cat anatomy: missing.”

My favorite evaluation is from a veteran teacher named Dorothy Stall, who wrote a report on Brown’s time assisting in her third-grade classroom. I don’t know anything about Dorothy Stall, but her report makes me like her tremendously. She is smart and often very funny when talking about Margaret Wise Brown: “Decidedly not the ‘school-teacher’ type, and despite all the progressive education, I’m afraid most of us fall into a type.”

Brown’s type, it turns out, was “writer.” Almost immediately upon enrolling in Bank Street’s teacher training program, Brown realized she didn’t want to teach children. Gradually, after spending time with kids, she realized she wanted to write for them. Even though Margaret Wise Brown was a bad teacher, she was really good with kids. Stall, like a lot of Brown’s instructors, described Brown as a captivating classroom presence: “Miss Brown could hold the whole group, for a half hour if they were discussing stories or a play that they were making.”

It’s a thrill to read that sentence today. Imagine the scene. Margaret Wise Brown, having long ago abandoned the lesson plan, is telling stories to kids. The children’s teacher, who has just seen Brown eat up thirty minutes of instructional time, is still impressed: Sure, Brown isn’t doing what she’s supposed to, but what she’s doing is magical, a worthwhile something else. Stall was an eyewitness to literary history, the birth of one of our best children’s writers.

Is it weird that I have, on multiple occasions, been moved to tears by a two-page typewritten administrative form titled “Report on Margaret Brown, student teacher at Little Red Schoolhouse by Dorothy Stall, 8 year old teacher”? I reread it often, and not just out of historical interest. In describing an unpromising schoolteacher, Stall created an early portrait of the “children’s writer” type. Many of Margaret Wise Brown’s weaknesses as a teacher are her strengths as a writer. And the report’s descriptions of Brown’s gifts are beautiful. In fact, I think Stall accidentally wrote one of kids’ books’ great art manifestos:

  • Weaknesses: Lack of group consciousness and realization of what has to happen to an individual’s whims and even real desires when he begins to function in a cooperative society. Lack of realization that something can be built up which makes escape necessary less and less often. Lack of interest in doing things with the hands.
  • Strength: Sensitiveness to beauty, to quality, and to the growth of individual personality.
  • Large group problems worried her because in solving them it seemed necessary to forget the individual child or ignore his personality and sometimes perhaps his rights.
  • Protective of the child against whatever she considered was being put over on him.
  • Strong sense of justice to the child as if she remembered her own childhood and wanted to make good to “the spirit of childhood” for the grown-ups who did not understand her.
  • Appreciation of the quality of our “little roughnecks”... Criticism of the way in which we “put over” subject matter on the children.
  • I feel that while many of the details of the work, especially connected to academic work, were neglected, or not seen as important, the spiritual contribution Miss Brown made to our little society far outweighed the defects. That I value more highly than anything else and the whole tone and attitude of the children toward each other and toward adults owes much to having had her with us.

The children’s writer is not a teacher. The children’s writer’s duty is to individual experience. Stall’s insight here is one we’re still struggling to learn. There are many adult figures in a child’s life – parents, grandparents, aunts, teachers, librarians, friends’ parents, clergy, pool lifeguards. All have different roles, which sometimes, but not always, overlap. There can be tensions between these roles, and that’s okay: Children benefit from a variety of perspectives. We all know this.

But adults often expect children’s books to reinforce the prerogatives of parents or priests or school principals. Most often, we confuse writers with teachers. There’s a large and loud contingent of adults – parents, teachers, librarians – who believe that a good kids’ book is one that teaches a clear lesson. Publishers and writers are all too happy to sell books to these customers. And so didacticism, ever the enemy of art, is rampant in kids’ books.

It’s well known that many of the earliest books for children were teaching tools, part of a medieval aristocratic education. These were printed editions of works already circulating in manuscript form, stuff like Stans puer ad mensam (“The Child at the Table,” a guide to manners) and The Babees Book, which famously states, “O Babees yynge, / My Book only is made for youre lernynge.”

The standard narrative is that didacticism just kind of got embedded in kids’ books from the very start and that writers have been working to get the stain out ever since. In Anglophone literature, Victorian writers like Beatrix Potter and Lewis Carroll, whose disgust with didacticism is all over the Alice stories, advanced the cause of storytelling over instruction, a battle that was won once and for all in the United States sometime in the mid-twentieth century, during children’s books’ great American golden age, when there was an explosion of ambitious works of children’s literature published to critical acclaim and commercial success.

This story is one of progress, the shaking off of medieval feudal-religious-patriarchal hierarchies in favor of the joys of literature. If you don’t like didacticism, it’s an appealing trajectory: Kids’ books started off preachy, but things have been getting better. The bad news is that the stories don’t really hold up.

Since the invention of the printing press, children’s books have been a battleground between those who want to tell kids what to do and those who want to tell them stories. There have been entertaining children’s books from the very beginning. It may be that the first children’s book ever printed in English was The Friar and Boy, which reads like proto–Roald Dahl: It’s about a kid who discovers a magic talisman, which he uses to control the awful adults around him, making them do embarrassing things like fart and dance badly.

And anyone who shops for children’s books today knows that that didactic tradition remains strong. Very strong. I have been publishing kids’ books for twenty years, long enough to have seen prevailing sentiments swing back and forth a few times. I am sad to report that didacticism is more dominant today than at any other time I’ve been writing.

Right now, in the US, it’s all about kindness. Over the last decade or so, generalized horror at the cruelty of the world got combined with an admirable effort to stamp out bullying in schools, which was then strapped to the good old American drive to make a buck, begetting a hulking kindness industrial complex. T-shirts. Sweatshirts. Pencils. Buttons. Silicone bracelets. Banners to hang on the wall of your kid’s bedroom. You name it, you can probably buy a version of it emblazoned with a slogan hailing kindness: Choose Kindness. Kindness Matters. Kind People Are My Kinda People. Grow Kindness (this sign has a picture of a bunch of flowers). Kindness Not Germs (this sign also tells you to wash your hands). Be Kind, It’s Really Not That Hard (ugh).

Just to be clear: I am pro-kindness. But I’m skeptical that these products are making Americans kinder. (They are doubtless making quite a few Americans richer.)

And now we have Kindness Reads, a marketing term for books that are usually about kind characters being kind to each other, though occasionally they’re about an unkind character who suddenly decides to be kind on the second-to-last page, and sometimes there aren’t any characters at all because it’s a poem with lines like “Kindness rules / Help at school / Kindness Kids are supercool.”

These Kindness Reads join a long tradition of books that are really just delivery systems for easily digestible, unobjectionable messages: “Be yourself!” “One small person can make a big difference!” “Together we can solve any problem!” These are lovely sentiments, but they make better bumper stickers than they do stories.

There are, of course, rich traditions of wisdom literature. Parables and fables come to mind, both of which have a special place in children’s books. But the best of these tend to contain startling truths about human nature, or state complex truths clearly, or somehow manage, while explaining the world, to remystify it. Even a story with a lesson should always be judged by how effectively that lesson is conveyed, not how worthy its message is or how important we think it is for kids to hear it. We can agree wholeheartedly with a book’s lesson and still deem it an artistic failure.

At worst, these books are counterproductive. How many children’s books will we market with the tagline “Dare to be different!” before we realize that we have created a literature that is flat, homogeneous, and boring? It is neither cool nor unique to tell kids, “It’s cool to be unique!” Instead of slogans, we need a rich, polyphonic, daring literature full of new and distinct voices, presenting a variety of perspectives and experiences. That would be cool!

[.pull-quote]In an educational culture increasingly fixated with quantification, the children’s writer must stubbornly champion the ineffable.[.pull-quote]

Didacticism tends to warp narrative, flatten characters, and mar beauty. Plots bend toward the author’s point. Protagonists are role models, not heroes. Epiphanies come out of nowhere. But the didactic impulse’s worst failing is an inability to imagine a child as anything other than a thing to be taught. There are genres that teach (textbooks, reference books, handbooks, and literary non-fiction are part of literature for adults and children alike) and books that aim to improve the reader’s moral well-being (spiritual and religious texts, collections of affirmations or aphorisms, and stuff on self-help, self-optimization, and self-improvement).

But fiction, or art fiction or literary fiction, is different. Rather than pushing a moral, good fiction invites the reader to make meaning. A moral is an immutable lesson, intentionally encoded into a story by the author, meant to be inscribed on the child’s brain. Meaning, though, is created collaboratively: Children bring their individual intelligence and experience to an artwork and, in tandem with its creators, decide what that story means to them.

Of course we learn things from art, but the things that we learn, and the ways that we learn them, are complicated and hard to describe. In an educational culture increasingly fixated with quantification, the children’s writer must stubbornly champion the ineffable. Stories are particularly good at ambiguity, complexity, paradox, and contradiction. A story’s best part is often some inexplicable extraneous bit, a knobby, knotty, or gristly thing that you can’t stop mulling afterward. And a good story tends to be irreducible. You can’t condense a story into a single sentence without doing great violence to it. I’m reminded of Leonard Cohen reading a poem on a radio show and, upon being asked by the host, “What does the poem mean?” reading the whole poem again.

That’s not to say a story cannot be examined or discussed. But upon examination a good story tends to get bigger. And when it’s discussed, you’re likely to find out that it means something different to someone else.

“Be kind” is where a story begins, not where it ends. “Be kind” is axiomatic, the type of thing we must all agree on for the story to even work. It is the unwritten prologue: “We should all be kind to each other, always. We all know that. It is true.”

But –

“Once upon a time there was a monster.”

“Once upon a time a boy who had nothing to eat walked past a blueberry pie cooling on a rich man’s windowsill.”

“Once upon a time a good mouse did something very bad.”

The children’s writer should not repeat to children the same bromides they hear everywhere, but endeavor to tell those truths that can be conveyed only in a story. That is our vocation, our unique role, the – to borrow a phrase from Margaret Wise Brown’s teacher Dorothy Stall – spiritual contribution we make to our little society.

[.smalltext]Source: Mac Barnett, Make Believe: On Telling Stories to Children (Little, Brown and Company, 2026). Used by permission of the publisher.[.smalltext]

Let us know what you think

Selected letters to the editor are published in each magazine issue.