The expansion of the churches was not organized – it simply happened.
Nevertheless the churches grew.3 Why? After AD 312, when the emperor Constantine I aligned himself with Christianity and began to promote it, the church’s growth is not hard to explain. But before Constantine the expansion is improbable enough to require a sustained attempt to understand it. The growth was odd. According to the evidence at our disposal, the expansion of the churches was not organized, the product of a mission program; it simply happened. Further, the growth was not carefully thought through. Early Christian leaders did not engage in debates between rival “mission strategies.” The Christians wrote a lot; according to classicist Robin Lane Fox, “most of the best Greek and Latin literature which remains [from the later second and third centuries] is Christian.”4 And what they wrote is surprising. The Christians wrote treatises on patience – three of them. But they did not write a single treatise on evangelism. Further, to assist their growing congregations with practical concerns, the Christians wrote “church orders,” manuals that provided guidance for the life and worship of congregations. The best treatment of how a second-century Christian should persuade a pagan to become a believer was published in London in 1970!5
liturgical scholars have called the disciplina arcani, the “discipline of the secret,” which barred outsiders from entering “private” Christian worship services and ordered believers not to talk to outsiders about what went on behind the closed doors.6, the churches did not use their worship services to attract new people. In the aftermath of the persecution of Nero in AD 68, churches around the empire – at varying speeds in varying places – closed their doors to outsiders. By the end of the second century, most of them had instituted what
The early Christians attributed the church’s growth to the patient work of God.
Fear motivated this closing – fear of people who might disrupt their gatherings or spy on them. By the third century, some churches assigned deacons to stand at the doors, monitoring the people as they arrived. It is not surprising that pagans responded to their exclusion from Christian worship by speculation and gossip.7 The baptized Christians, on the other hand, knew how powerful the worship services were in their own lives – early fourth-century North African believers said simply, “We cannot go without the Lord’s Supper.” They knew that worship services were to glorify God and edify the faithful, not to evangelize outsiders.8
And yet, improbably, the movement was growing. In number, size, and geographical spread, churches were expanding without any of the probable prerequisites for church growth. The early Christians noted this with wonder and attributed it to the patient work of God.9 Teaching catechumens in Caesarea around AD 240, Origen observed that throughout history God had been faithful to Israel, sending them prophets, turning them back from their sins.
See how great the harvest is, even though there are few workers. But also in another way God plans always that the net is thrown on the lake of this life, and all kinds of fish are caught. He sends out many fishers, he sends out many hunters, they hunt from every hill. See how great a plan it is concerning the salvation of the nations.10
The churches grew because the faith that these fishers and hunters embodied was attractive to people who were dissatisfied with their old cultural and religious habits, who felt pushed to explore new possibilities, and who then encountered Christians who embodied a new manner of life that pulled them toward what the Christians called “rebirth” into a new life.11
“We do not speak great things but we live them.”
12 As we rediscover this bequest, we will not make facile generalizations or construct how-to formulas. Instead, we will say with Cyprian and other early Christians: “We do not speak great things but we live them.”13must live with this heritage. We will not do things precisely as the early Christians did, but the early believers may give us new perspectives and point us to a “lost bequest.”
Kreider, Alan. The Patient Ferment of the Early Church: The Improbable Rise of Christianity in the Roman Empire, Baker Academic, a division of Baker Publishing Group, 2016. Used by permission.
- Apostolic Tradition 19.2; Cyprian, To Quirinius 3.16–18; Didascalia apostolorum 5.6.2. Footnotes are abridged in this excerpt; for the full notes, see Alan Kreider, The Patient Ferment of the Early Church (Baker, 2016).
- Gustave Bardy, La conversion au christianisme durant les premiers siècles (Aubier, 1949), 170.
- For an overview, see The Oxford Handbook of Early Christian Studies, ed. Susan Ashbrook Harvey and David Hunter (Oxford, 2008), 283–386.
- Robin Lane Fox, Pagans and Christians (Harper & Row, 1986), 270.
- Michael Green, Evangelism in the Early Church (Hodder & Stoughton, 1970), chaps. 3, 5–6.
- Edward Yarnold, The Awe-Inspiring Rites of Initiation (St. Paul, 1971), 50–51.
- Minucius Felix, Octavius 9.3.
- Acts of the Abitinian Martyrs 12.
- Norbert Brox, “Zur christlichen Mission in der Spätantike,” in Mission im Neuen Testament (Herder, 1982), 207.
- Origen, Homilies on Jeremiah 18.5.3, trans. J. C. Smith.
- Justin, First Apology 61.3–4, 10; Cyprian, To Donatus 3–4.
- Roger Dowley, Towards the Recovery of a Lost Bequest (Evangelical Coalition for Urban Mission, 1984).
- Cyprian, On the Good of Patience 3.